Eye tracking reveals the hidden power of painted hands
A new eye-tracking experiment reveals that the pointing gestures painted into classic artworks secretly act as guides for human vision. Even though viewers barely look at the painted hands, these small details completely reshape how we understand the artwork.
A recent psychological study has uncovered the concealed influence of painted hands in early modern paintings. The research, published in a scientific journal, found that tiny details like pointing fingers shape how people perceive artwork. The concept of the "admonitor," a figure pointing to a key element in the scene, dates back to theatrical plays from the 15th century.
Artists later incorporated this technique into their paintings to guide viewers' attention and establish visual connections. Despite the prominence of pointing hands in art history, researchers had never empirically tested their impact on modern viewers. To investigate, a team led by Temenuzhka Dimova from the University of Vienna conducted an experiment with 84 adults, none of whom had a background in art history.
The team selected 15 European paintings from the 16th and 17th centuries, focusing on works by Caravaggio, Raphael, and Rembrandt. The researchers digitally removed the pointing fingers from digital reproductions of these paintings, creating two versions for each artwork. Participants viewed both original and edited paintings, unaware of the modifications.
Eye-tracking equipment measured where participants looked and for how long. Surprisingly, viewers spent only half a second directly on the pointing fingers, accounting for just 1.5% of their total viewing time. Despite the minimal direct attention, the presence of pointing fingers significantly influenced viewers' overall experience.
In original paintings, the pointing gesture guided participants to the intended target and encouraged them to examine the character's face, creating a strong visual link between the two. In the modified versions, participants fixated on the central character or scattered their gaze over decorative elements. The absence of a pointing finger disrupted the visual equilibrium, forcing viewers to form new relationships between the remaining characters.
Participants' verbal descriptions of the paintings also changed. When viewing the original Caravaggio piece depicting the sacrifice of Isaac, many participants specifically mentioned the ram pointed to by an angel. Those who saw the modified version rarely mentioned the animal. The pointing gesture successfully highlighted a key narrative element in the original work.
In Raphael's painting featuring two visual levels, viewers of the original piece felt the upper and lower scenes were connected, identifying two pointing characters as the main link. Viewers of the altered piece saw the two scenes as entirely separate. While the pointing hands guided viewers' eyes, their influence on understanding the artwork's story was more significant.
The researchers noted that viewers sometimes fixated on unintended objects, but the overall effect of the pointing gestures was clear: they helped shape how people perceived and interpreted the artwork's narrative.
Written by urgent.news from PsyPost's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — it may contain errors, so check the original before relying on it.
