Unfortunate Statistics Show Why J.J. McCarthy Lost Vikings Starting Job

The Minnesota Vikings have reportedly decided that veteran quarterback Kyler Murray will be the starting quarterback over younger J.J. McCarthy, a decision supported by statistics. McCarthy is entering his third professional season after being drafted 10th overall by the Vikings. He missed his rookie campaign due to injury, but started 10 games last year, resulting in a 6-4 record for the team.

Despite their success, McCarthy's performance left much to be desired. According to football analyst Warren Sharp, McCarthy's passing game was significantly below average. He threw at a level that placed him with a list of former NFL quarterbacks who have struggled, including names like Richardson and Sanders. Sharp highlighted that quarterbacks with an Expected Points Added (EPA) of -0.10 or worse, a completion percentage of 59% or less, and an interception rate of 3% or worse have generally struggled or failed in the league.

Richardson, currently a Colts' fourth-round pick, is seeking a trade after facing criticism. Sanders, a second-year player, also faces a tough battle for the Cleveland Browns' starting position against Watson, an established veteran. Josh Rosen, another top 10 draft pick, has struggled so much that he left the NFL altogether to pursue an MBA.

The statistics suggest that players with such performance metrics rarely make it in the NFL. While NFL insider Adam Schefter believes McCarthy is still young and has time to improve, for now, he will be the backup quarterback.