Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across hundreds of outlets.

Tech

Temporal.io vs Cadence vs AWS Step Functions: Distributed Workflow Orchestration & State Durability

Temporal.io vs Cadence vs AWS Step Functions: Distributed Workflow Orchestration & State Durability Executive Summary & Decision Matrix All three systems solve the same core problem — durable execution: a workflow function's logical progress is checkpointed to durable storage so that process crashes, deploys, and hardware failures never lose state or duplicate side effects. The divergence is in…

Three popular distributed workflow orchestration systems, Temporal.io, Cadence, and AWS Step Functions, all address the challenge of ensuring durable execution of workflow functions. The primary difference lies in their implementation methods and ownership of infrastructure costs.

Temporal.io and Cadence share a common open-source codebase, with Temporal forking Cadence in 2019 to improve storage layer and SDK ergonomics. Both are self-hostable, database-backed state machines, while AWS Step Functions is a managed, closed-source JSON/Amazon States Language interpreter relying on AWS-internal durability primitives.

The benchmark used for this comparison involved a 64-vCPU c6i.32xlarge Temporal/Cadence worker cluster, backed by Aurora PostgreSQL 15. The same state-machine topology was used to drive a synthetic "order saga" workflow with six activities, each with a 2KB payload, and a 30% simulated failure-retry rate. AWS Step Functions was benchmarked via the public API with the same state-machine topology, using the Standard workflow class.

Throughput metrics show Temporal (1.28 workflows/sec) and Cadence (0.28 workflows/sec) outperforming AWS Step Functions (2,000 state transitions/sec) in terms of sustained workflow throughput per 8-node cluster or per account. Activity dispatch latency is also notably lower for Temporal and Cadence (p50 3.1 ms vs. 62 ms for Step Functions) and (p99 11 ms vs. 310 ms for Step Functions).

State durability SLA differs between the systems. Temporal and Cadence offer self-owned durability (Aurora: 99.999% with multi-AZ), while AWS Step Functions provides 99.999% execution history durability, which includes AWS SLA of 4 nines API availability.

The storage cost per 1M completed workflow histories varies significantly. Temporal (Aurora gp3) and Cadence cost $18.40 and $22.10, respectively, while AWS Step Functions costs $2.47 per 1M transitions. Max event history size differs as well, with Temporal and Cadence supporting up to 50,000 events and 2MB per payload, while AWS Step Functions allows 25,000 events and 256KB per state.

Worker SDK languages differ across the systems. Temporal and Cadence support multiple languages such as Go, Java, TypeScript, Python, PHP, .NET, and Rust, while AWS Step Functions supports any language via HTTP/Lambda, with the SDK available only for state-machine authoring.

Timer and heartbeat precision also differ, with Temporal/Cadence offering 10 ms granularity and a ~5ms drift under load, while AWS Step Functions provides 33 ms granularity and a minimum of 1 second, with ±1s drift.

Replay engine determinism bugs are present in Temporal (3 pinned-version issues) and Cadence (11 weaker SDK fingerprinting and workflow-versioning story). In contrast, AWS Step Functions does not have code replay capabilities, interpreting JSON state machines instead.

At an annual cost of $9,800 for 50 million executions per month with 100 transitions each, Temporal (3 replicas + Aurora) and Cadence (Cassandra ops tax) incur higher operational costs, while AWS Step Functions at $126,500 per month delivers lower total cost of ownership due to zero infrastructure ownership.

Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.

Source: dev.to

Read the original at dev.to →

Report a problem with this story

More in Tech

Cloud costs were never a technology problem

I've been sharing what I see inside cloud accounts for months now Real accounts. Real numbers. Real messes and real fixes Here's what it all adds up to Cloud costs are not a technical problem The…

  • Cloud costs stem from human factors, not technical issues
  • Disconnection between resource provisioners and bill reviewers leads to visibility gaps
  • Regular review and documentation prevent cost crises

Why Your Slow-Query Log Is Lying to You (a Little)

You've done the obvious work. You pulled a slow-query log off production, found the worst offenders, added indexes, rewrote a couple of queries, and shipped it. Response times improved.

  • Slow-query logs show queries over usual runtime but miss some cases
  • They don't capture rarely hit queries or cache state dependent problems
  • Enable SAVEQUERIES in WordPress for full query profiling during debugging

Why Your Full-Page Cache Needs an Opinion About Query Strings

Two different incidents on the same WordPress VIP-style multisite network, months apart, turned out to share one root cause.

  • Full-page cache key should not be determined by request contents.
  • Query strings often cause false cache misses due to tracking parameters.
  • Explicitly vary headers that genuinely affect response to prevent false caches.

More from Sunday 22 November →