Mengapa pegawai takut tegur ketua tidak berintegriti?
Kita sering menyeru warga organisasi supaya berani melaporkan salah laku. Namun, persoalannya, sejauh manakah mereka benar-benar dilindungi?
In every organization, a question that must be pondered is why there are still employees who know about acts such as bribery, misuse of position, breach of trust, conflict of interest, and rule violations, yet choose to remain silent. Are they unaware that such actions are wrong? Are they lacking in principles of integrity? Or is it fear that they may lose their job, promotion opportunities, ranks, and future career prospects for daring to speak out against their superiors?
This is among the serious diseases that need attention in both public and private sector organizational culture. More concerning when it is employees who are supposed to uphold integrity who ultimately choose to protect the interests of their superiors. When a superior makes a mistake, subordinates opt to stay silent. When subordinates voice an opinion, they are considered problematic.
Ultimately, the guilty continue to dominate while the honest must bear the consequences. In a healthy organization, criticism should be a mechanism for rectifying weaknesses, not perceived as a threat to a leader's position. However, there are organizations that create a culture of fear to speak out. Employees who voice differing opinions are perceived as disrespectful, disloyal, difficult to work with, or having disciplinary issues.
Worse, employees who dare to highlight management weaknesses may face pressure, exclusion from important tasks, denial of certain opportunities, or reassignment to other departments. If such conditions persist, what message is being communicated to the organization's workforce? Don't speak out if you want to survive. Don't criticize if you want career growth.
Don't question a leader's decision even if it seems questionable. This is the beginning of the end of integrity culture. One major mistake in an organization is equating loyalty to the leader with the ability to uphold all actions of the leader, including actions that conflict with laws, regulations, and principles of integrity.
True loyalty does not mean blindly following every order without questioning its correctness. An integrity-driven employee must have the courage to advise, criticize, and report mistakes through the proper channels. The leader must also understand that the position they hold does not grant immunity from criticism, scrutiny, or legal action.
Don't use the word 'loyalty' as an excuse to justify wrongdoing. Don't use rank as a shield to protect wrongdoing. Organizations do not need employees who only know how to praise and crave every decision made by a leader. Organizations need employees who are brave enough to state the truth even when it is not popular. A leader afraid of being criticized lacks leadership skills.
A leader with integrity will not feel threatened when receiving justified criticism. Instead, they will professionally evaluate the criticism and take corrective action if there is a weakness. However, if a leader perceives every criticism as a threat to their authority, opposes employees with differing opinions, or uses their position to pressure critics, issues regarding the maturity and integrity of their leadership need to be raised.
A great leader cannot be a leader feared for their power, but a leader respected for their integrity. We often urge organization members to be brave enough to report wrongdoing. However, the question remains, how truly protected are they? In January 2023, media reports highlighted the concern of civil servants for becoming informants, with allegations that some employees feared dismissal, reassignment, or damage to their career prospects after making a complaint against superiors.
In April 2026, the Ethics and Integrity Commission (EAIC) also emphasized that fear of retaliation is among the challenges in promoting whistle-blowing. This cannot be taken lightly. If a whistle-blowing employee ends up being the victim while the reported party continues to enjoy their position and privileges, how can we build moral courage within the organization?
The whistle-blowing mechanism must function, not merely be listed in documents and regulations. It must include confidentiality of identity, free evaluation of complaints, action against any illegal retaliation, and a trusted reporting channel. Being brave only against subordinates is not enough. The Integrity Unit in an organization must also have the necessary access to higher-ranking officials, freedom to perform professional functions, and assurance that complaints against high-ranking officials will not be controlled by individuals with vested interests in the matter. Integrity knows no rank. Law should not bow to power.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
Source: freemalaysiatoday.com
Other reports of this story
- Mengapa pegawai takut tegur ketua tidak berintegriti? freemalaysiatoday.com