I spent a day breaking my own eval tool's scoring rule, and it was the best use of the day
This is the developer-facing version of a post I published on AI Stack Lab: Your Eval Suite Is Theater Until a Non-Zero Exit Code Stops the Merge . Same measurements, different angle — this one is about the scoring rule itself. I spent a day breaking my own eval tool's scoring rule, and it was the best use of the day Last week I shipped a $1 CLI called AIEval that does exactly one thing: read a…
This reporter spent a day testing their own evaluation tool's scoring rule, and found it to be a valuable use of time. The evaluation tool, called AIEval, is a simple command-line interface that compares recorded model answers to expected strings and exits with a non-zero code if accuracy falls below a certain threshold. The reporter built a set of tests with a 0.80 accuracy threshold and fed it answers that should not pass.
To their surprise, three out of four verdicts came from substring behavior, not the model being right or wrong. This highlights the trap of measuring accuracy based on short tokens, as the accuracy number can be partially a coincidence. To avoid this, the reporter suggests using expected strings that a wrong answer cannot accidentally contain.
The reporter also discovered that a missing response is considered a failure, not a skip, and that max_avg_latency_ms is inert and not enforced by the harness. The evaluation process can be simplified to a single non-zero exit code in a CI step, making it easier to detect model regressions.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
Source: dev.to