Die Steuer, die nicht weh tut - und darum gefährlich ist
Die Mehrwertsteuer ist bequem, weil sie kaum jemand spürt. Gerade deshalb ist die geplante Erhöhung für die 13. AHV-Rente problematisch.
The value-added tax (VAT) is convenient because most people are unaware of its impact. This is why the proposed increase to fund the 13th AHV pension is problematic. In early December, approximately 2.6 million pensioners will receive their first 13th AHV pension. Just a few days before, the public decided how this funding would be financed.
The federal council and parliament propose raising the VAT from 8.5% starting in 2028. This may seem insignificant, but there is a danger in this seemingly minor increase. The VAT is a popular tool for fiscal policy, viewed as growth-friendly unlike income tax. It also serves as a fairness argument: those who benefit from the 13th pension contribute to it as well, just like higher wage contributions.
Moreover, the reduced rate for food and medication remains unchanged, sparing those with smaller budgets. However, this positive perspective overlooks important aspects. Besides economic distortions caused by the VAT, its comparative efficiency holds a political double-edged sword. In the 1980s, economist Larry Summers explained why the US had no VAT: left-leaning individuals viewed it as unsocial, while conservatives saw it as a "money machine" for the state.
Only when political roles were reversed would it come into existence. To date, no nationwide VAT exists. The fear of such a money machine is economically justified. Economists Gary Becker and Casey Mulligan argue that more efficient taxes could weaken political resistance to higher government spending. With additional revenue readily available, the pressure to limit spending decreases.
In cross-country comparisons, heavier taxes with relatively low rates often coincide with larger government budgets. Whether the VAT leads to higher government spending remains an open question. Additionally, there's the issue of low visibility: easier-to-raise taxes go unnoticed. A study by economist Amy Finkelstein on American toll roads found that, when tolls were paid electronically instead of in cash, they were 20 to 40 percent higher long-term.
Similarly, the VAT is concealed within the price. Buyers rarely notice how much of it goes towards the 13th pension. Higher wage contributions, however, appear on every paycheck, while pension cuts are immediately felt by those affected. The less visible the cost, the lower the resistance. Switzerland provides an example. In 1995, the VAT was introduced at 6.5%.
In 1999, the 1993-voted Demographic Coefficient for the 13th pension was approved, in 2011 a temporary boost for the IV pension, in 2024 an additional 0.4% for the 13th AHV. Each increase was justified individually and politically manageable. Yet, in total, the VAT has become a convenient relief valve for uncomfortable reforms. The 13th AHV pension funding shows this exemplarily: it received 55% approval, while the higher retirement age for women only garnered a thin majority.
However, the proposed increase is insufficient to fully fund the 13th AHV pension. It already costs over 4 billion francs in the first year, projected to exceed 5 billion by 2035 according to the Federal Office for Social Insurance. The VAT contributes only around 1.4 billion francs annually to the 13th AHV. Yet, the Bundesrat projects a budget deficit of around 3 billion francs by 2035.
The 13th AHV fund may shrink to around 70% of annual expenditure by then. The real problem lies deeper. The baby boomers are retiring, life expectancy is increasing, and the male retirement age remains at 65 years – unchanged since the AHV's introduction in 1948. More pension years must be funded. To secure our main social insurance long-term, adjusting the retirement age is almost unavoidable.
How this is done politically is up for debate. Flexible models, such as a life-span work period where earnings are considered instead of age, are worth discussing if they don't become overly bureaucratic. Nevertheless, long-term solutions are necessary. Voting 'yes' on November 29th provides some breathing room for the 13th AHV.
Voting 'no' increases the pressure for reform. Both are justifiable, but the risk lies in the convenient financing obscuring necessary reforms. That is the danger of the money machine. Melanie Häner-Müller, head of the social policy area at the Institute for Swiss Economic Policy (IWP) at the University of Luzern, suggests raising the retirement age instead of relying on the VAT.
The left-leaning advocates higher wage deductions, while some contest the need for action altogether. A narrow majority opposes the additional funding for the 13th AHV, as shown by a GfS survey commissioned by the SRG. Even the Reformed Party, previously against the 13th pension, now supports the VAT increase. Former party president explains how the political system intends to pay for rising social expenditures and why he is not a social populist.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
Source: nzz.ch