Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Business

Handynetz: Rückschlag für Mobilfunker 1&1 - Beschwerde in Brüssel

Vor drei Jahren startete 1&1 sein eigenes Handynetz, die Platzhirsche Telekom, Vodafone und O2 waren nicht begeistert. 1&1 wollte alsbald mit zusätzlichen Frequenzen nachrüsten. Daraus wird nichts.

Original German Read in English

Handynetz: Rückschlag für Mobilfunker 1&1 - Beschwerde in Brüssel

The newcomer to the mobile network market, 1&1, has faced a setback as it was excluded from participating in the auction and renewal of mobile frequencies in 2025. Established telecom operators Deutsche Telekom, Vodafone, and O2 did not relinquish any frequencies, and the Federal Network Agency did not impose strict measures, according to a recent administrative decision.

The existing frequency rights were extended by five years until the end of 2030, and the established operators benefited financially from this decision, as the agency postponed and rescheduled the auction and renewal of frequencies. 1&1 was left out of the process.

The Federal Network Agency decided that 1&1 would not need to provide any frequencies to the established operators, instead, it obliged Vodafone to provide national roaming for 1&1. In regions where 1&1 does not have its own antennas, customers will be connected to Vodafone's antennas. For this, 1&1 pays rent. However, 1&1 had already signed a national roaming contract with Vodafone, so nothing changed for them.

The agency did not consider the decision to be a financial disadvantage for 1&1 and did not promote the goal of a fair competition. According to a spokesperson for the Federal Network Agency, "National roaming is the most appropriate variant to implement cooperative co-location."

Vodafone's spokesperson praised the agency's decision as well, stating it was fair and balanced. 1&1, on the other hand, strongly criticized the decision and announced a subsidy complaint in Brussels. They intend to seek the opinion of the European Commission on whether there is any unlawful state aid to Deutsche Telekom, Vodafone, and O2 Telefónica.

The frequencies are a public and scarce asset of significant economic value, and 1&1 claims that the three established operators received them well below their market value without competitive bidding. As a result, 1&1 will continue to rely on national roaming in the Vodafone network, even in areas where they already have their own antennas.

1&1 first bid for mobile frequency rights in 2019 to build the fourth German mobile network, paying €1.1 billion at the time. After a slow start, the expansion began, and the antennas of the United-Internet subsidiary now cover 37 percent of German households, with the goal of reaching 40 percent by the end of the year. Where 1&1 does not have its own network, Vodafone provides national roaming.

In the expected auction for 2025, 1&1 aimed to secure "low band" frequencies that cover large areas and work well indoors. The agency decided in March 2025 to extend the frequency rights by five years, with associated fees, as the auction costs would likely have been significantly higher. This potential financial advantage for established operators annoyed the newcomer 1&1.

The Federal Network Agency had given the company from Rhineland-Palatinate faint hopes, but no access to frequencies was granted. The agency decided that the established operators should negotiate with 1&1 to possibly transfer some spectrum. The negotiations took place over a year, but the agency closed the chapter after a year and a half.

Written by urgent.news from Handelsblatt's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at handelsblatt.com →

More in Business

More from Thursday 19 November →