Why school districts are using corporate buzzwords to rebrand painful school closures
Did you know search engines like Google are changing the way you see news? Keep Chalkbeat’s valuable education coverage at the top of your feeds by clicking here and checking the box next to our name. A sleek Minneapolis school district webpage markets a “districtwide effort to reimagine a district where every student thrives.” A Tucson, Arizona school district presentation promises that the…
School districts across the United States are increasingly employing corporate jargon to rebrand the closure of their schools. This buzzword-heavy messaging aims to mask the pain of closures, which are often driven by declining birth rates, relocation due to affordability, and growth in charter schools. Despite the fanciful language, the core issue remains the same: school closures are a means to reinvent and reimagine the educational landscape, offering better spaces and greater opportunities for students.
Companies specializing in the business of shrinking school districts provide a hand to these districts in crafting these messages. They argue that if districts fail to reduce their footprint, financial problems will only worsen, pushing schools into a downward spiral. However, critics contend that the lofty language used by districts does little to alleviate the anxieties of communities that often face harsh consequences from closures.
Take Tucson, Arizona for example. The district is currently facing the closure of Collier Elementary, where second grader Alexis Cervantes is enrolled. The district's superintendent claims the closure is about creating a superior academic product, a narrative that feels disingenuous to Cervantes who is fighting the closure. She asserts that while improvements are welcome, the closure announcement feels more like a label slapped on to make the decision seem more palatable.
Consultants play a significant role in shaping the language surrounding school closures. They help districts like Atlanta decide which schools to close and work with Fort Worth in their decision to close seven schools. However, the effectiveness of these consultants in maintaining trust among communities is questioned. Considerations such as community engagement and recognizing the grief of the community are important, but also require a careful balance to avoid overpromising and underdelivering.
Written by urgent.news from Chalkbeat's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.