Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Business

Bundestagswahl steht: BSW scheitert in Karlsruhe: Was die Entscheidung bedeutet

Der Beschluss aus Karlsruhe hätte Merz Regierung die Mehrheit kosten können. Stattdessen besiegelt er die Wahlniederlage des BSW. Die Partei übt scharfe Kritik.

Original German Read in English

Bundestagswahl steht: BSW scheitert in Karlsruhe: Was die Entscheidung bedeutet

Just over 21 months after Germany's federal election, the country's highest court delivered a verdict that the votes will not be recounted and the official final result remains unchanged. The Bundestagswahl (federal election) outcome stands, and the BSW (Bundestagswacht - Bundestag Watch) is not entering the parliament. This is the outcome of a month-long and 78-page election review by the Federal Constitutional Court.

It dismissed a complaint from the BSW. Thus, a long-drawn-out process with potentially major consequences has finally been decided. CDU Chancellor Friedrich Merz (Christian Democratic Union), the red-black coalition and the rest of the parties in the Bundestag now have one less concern - unlike the 2024 BSW founded by Sahra Wagenknecht.

For the political system, the question remains how future disputed election results will be dealt with. What if? The BSW sought a recount to gain at least 35 parliamentarians in the Bundestag. In the best case, Merz could have lost his majority, because all mandates would have been redistributed. "This government would certainly have been toppled in this form," explained Potsdam political scientist Jan Philipp Thomeczek after the Karlsruhe ruling.

Red-Black could have possibly needed the Greens as a partner, or new elections could have been held. All this is off the table. Instead, the result of the election review process is primarily a setback for the BSW. "This was certainly a straw man that the BSW had clung to," said Thomeczek, who has been dealing with the Wagenknecht party for years.

"Now they are really left wondering how to proceed." What did the BSW seek? Wagenknecht harshly criticized the Karlsruhe decision and called it a "mistake": "It does not protect the constitution, but damages democracy and finally destroys the trust in the rule of law that has been massively shaken since the Corona era." The Federal Constitutional Court judges criticized the arguments as unsubstantiated and declared the election complaint inadmissible.

"The requirements for establishing such a complaint are not met, a sufficiently concrete factual basis is not presented," the court said. "The mere mention of the possibility of electoral errors or the expression of an unsubstantiated assumption does not satisfy the requirements for proving an electoral error." The fact that the BSW was so close to the five-percent hurdle does not matter to the court in terms of the requirements for establishing an electoral error.

It emphasized that the decision was unanimous. Why is the BSW treated so fundamentally? Wagenknecht said: "Now it is officially: Germany has the election review of a banana republic - with highest court approval." Party leader Fabio De Masi spoke of a "black day for democracy", party chair Amira Mohamed Ali called it a scandal. In addition to the court ruling, the BSW also presented arguments.

"After this Karlsruhe ruling, in the future no party will have a real chance of getting a review in case of narrow results and obvious irregularities," Wagenknecht explained. "From now on, genuine vote fraud could also occur without the affected party being able to defend itself against it." Mohamed Ali formulated it as: "With this ruling from Karlsruhe, it remains unclear whether the Bundestag is correctly composed and unfairly denies parliamentary representation to the approximately 2.5 million BSW voters."

What comes next with the election review? This actually leaves doubt for everyone except the BSW. "It is indeed a difficult procedure," said Thomeczek. At the heart of the Basic Law, if there are complaints against an election result, the Bundestag is initially responsible. In the case of the BSW, the plenary rejected a request for a recount on December 18, 2025.

Then the party had the option of going to Karlsruhe - as the Federal Constitutional Court itself made clear directly after the election. "The procedure is too long and cumbersome," said Martin Plum, a Justice official of the Union faction at the "Rheinischen Post". He sees the need for reform. "From now on, the election review should be solely the responsibility of the Federal Constitutional Court," Plum said. This would, in his view, speed up the process and "promote trust in our democracy".

Written by urgent.news from Handelsblatt's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at handelsblatt.com →

More in Business

ADB deepens support to mobilize private investment in Bangladesh

The Asian Development Bank (ADB) has reaffirmed its commitment to helping Bangladesh attract long-term private investment, diversify its economy, and expand sustainable infrastructure financing. During November 16-18, ADB Director General (DG) for South Asia Sona Shrestha led a One-ADB delegation to Dhaka for high-level discussions with…

More from Wednesday 18 November →