A flawed test for African banks
Why pressuring African multilateral banks to accept foreign ownership is unjustified.
In June 2025, Fitch reduced the credit rating of the Africa Export-Import Bank, igniting a heated discussion regarding the evaluations of multilateral development banks by international rating agencies. Later, in February, Moody's proposed modifications to its assessment approach for these financial entities. These changes, implemented since July, could lead to a downgrade of up to two notches if a bank lacks significant, highly-rated, and non-borrowing shareholders.
This could complicate African-owned development banks' efforts to secure higher ratings without attracting non-African shareholders, potentially requiring them to relinquish a portion of their ownership and control. Credit ratings aim to provide an impartial evaluation of an institution's ability and willingness to repay its debts.
However, rating methodologies for multilateral banks have shown a tendency to favor non-African shareholders, implying that African governments, regardless of their financial contributions, might not provide sufficient capital to the institutions they have established. While the nationality of shareholders might be relevant to risk analysis, it should not replace the examination of fundamental factors.
If a bank demonstrates robust risk management and governance, adequate capitalization, quality assets, and high liquidity, the shareholders' origins should be less significant. Foreign investment and diverse shareholding are beneficial, but they should be strategic choices made by the institutions themselves, not conditions imposed by the credit assessment system.
A more critical issue lies in the distinction between paid-in capital and callable capital. For Afreximbank, shareholders' funds amount to around $9 billion, while its net income rose by 30% in the first half of 2026. African governments have also contributed significantly, with $2.6 billion in additional paid-in capital by the end of 2025 and an additional $526 million in cash contributions in 2026.
Despite these substantial commitments, Moody's new methodology continues to prioritize callable capital from foreign, highly-rated shareholders over significant paid-in capital from African shareholders. Credit rating methodologies that emphasize geographical concentration and an exclusive focus on the African business environment are creating a structural disadvantage for African-owned multilateral development banks, which are mandated to serve African economies.
To achieve higher credit ratings, these institutions must reduce lending to the very economies they were created to support, potentially undermining their core mission. Rating agencies must not overlook weaknesses in African governance, capital adequacy, liquidity, or risk management. Maintaining independence and analytical integrity is crucial for the credibility of the ratings industry.
To uphold these standards, three changes are required. First, ratings should be accurate and consistent, ensuring that African institutions are not penalized solely due to their shareholders' nationalities, which should not be mistaken for financial capacity. Second, African governments must continue to support their institutions with capital and uphold their legal commitments, which should allow rating agencies to assess multilateral banks based on their legal and operational merits.
Lastly, African countries must enhance collaboration among their multilateral financial institutions, bolster domestic capital markets, and foster the development of independent African credit rating capacity. Increasing competition and analytical diversity will improve credit assessments, provided all agencies maintain rigorous standards.
Without addressing these issues, Africa may struggle to establish robust multilateral financial institutions if the cost of recognition is the surrender of ownership and control to foreign shareholders.
Written by urgent.news from Semafor's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.