The Great New York–Florida Debate
Which state’s taxpayers get more for their money? The question cannot be answered just by comparing budget lines.
In the wake of the midterm blue wave, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis continued to emphasize the merits of governance in red states during his re-election campaign. During an event sponsored by the Institute for Legal Reform, DeSantis claimed that Florida's budget stood at $117 billion, while New York's budget was twice that amount at $268 billion. He argued that despite this disparity, New York residents were not enjoying superior roads, infrastructure, or services.
The difference in budget allocation between the two states largely stemmed from education and Medicaid spending, which are the largest expenditure categories in most state budgets. Education expenditure accounted for up to a quarter of the budget difference, with New York spending an average of $32,000 per K–12 student, the highest in the nation.
In contrast, Florida spent around $13,000 per student, placing it sixth-lowest in the country. This disparity was primarily driven by teacher compensation, with New York teachers receiving an average salary of $99,000, the second-highest in the country, while Florida teachers earned the least at $57,000 on average. New York also employed significantly more teachers and instructional aides, while offering three times as many employee benefits per pupil compared to Florida.
However, the benefits of higher spending in New York schools did not translate into better educational outcomes. According to the National Assessment of Education Progress, Florida students performed better in fourth-grade reading and math, while New York students scored slightly higher in eighth-grade reading and math. The primary beneficiaries of increased spending were the state's teachers, who enjoyed improved compensation and job security due to a state law known as the Triborough Amendment.
This law ensured that teachers' union contracts did not expire, leading to consistently higher raises for members.
Medicaid spending represented another significant gap between the two states, with New York spending $89 billion and Florida spending $34 billion on the program for fiscal year 2025. While Medicaid was funded primarily by the federal government, the states made their own decisions regarding who and what to cover. New York, in line with President Lyndon B. Johnson's vision, expanded Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act, offering coverage to individuals earning up to 138 percent of the federal poverty line.
In addition to this, the state provided $32 billion in federal assistance through the "Essential Plan" for residents earning up to two times the poverty line. Florida, on the other hand, had not expanded Medicaid and covered fewer individuals, resulting in 22% of nonelderly Floridians in poverty without insurance, compared to 9% and 8% in New York.
Written by urgent.news from The Atlantic's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.