Our Payment Controls Trust a Director's Voice and a Convincing Copy of It Can Now Be Made From One Speech
Our finance team has a rule I was proud of. Any request to pay a supplier outside the weekly run, or to change a supplier's bank details, must be confirmed by phone with a director. The director's voice is the check. In 2024 the engineering firm Arup confirmed that an employee in its Hong Kong office had transferred about twenty million pounds after a video call with people who looked and sounded…
The finance team at Arup follows a rule that any payment to a supplier outside the weekly cycle, or a change in a supplier's bank details, must be confirmed over the phone with a director. This voice serves as the safety net. In 2024, an engineering employee in Hong Kong transferred around £20 million by deceiving people who appeared to be the company's chief financial officer and colleagues, through a video call using synthetic voices.
An accounts assistant received a voice message from the managing director asking for an urgent payment via a new haulier. The assistant followed the rule by confirming the request with a call to the director's mobile, which was unanswered. The control worked because the director was unreachable, not due to the strength of the rule.
The rule assumed that recognizing a voice confirmed the speaker's identity, a reasonable assumption when voice imitation required skill. However, with advancements in synthetic voice technology and live video, anyone can now convincingly mimic a voice, rendering voice recognition unreliable. To address this, the finance team has moved the verification process out of the conversation.
Payments outside the weekly cycle are now approved directly in their banking platform, where each approver signs in with their own second factor, and phone calls to confirm bank details no longer suffice. Urgency is now treated as a reason to slow down the process. The directors have agreed in writing that they will never ask anyone to bypass the process.
The most effective controls are those that don't rely on recognizing a person, as attackers can replicate voices from recordings.
Written by urgent.news from Dev.to's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.