Github Redesign
I suggest the conversation steer away from the controversial last point where he flattens the UI quite a bit to make it less "dated", as the rest was quite good up until that point, and that deserves being discussed. Comments
GitHub's design is functional and clean, offering a consistent visual language suitable for daily use. However, there are several areas for improvement. To begin with, let's examine the repository page interface and identify the issues it presents.
One of the primary concerns is the information architecture, particularly the presence of nested tabs. These tabs are nested under one another, making them difficult for non-programmers to grasp, remember, and navigate. Additionally, the grouping of these tabs is often non-intuitive. Nested tabs are considered one of the worst UI patterns due to their complexity.
Another usability issue arises when users need to access releases within a repository. There is no explicit "Releases" tab visible, forcing users to deduce that releases are part of the codebase. This is illogical, as releases are as relevant to the code as issues or wikis.
To address these issues, we can flatten all tabs into a single navigational control, making them more accessible from anywhere within the repository. This change not only improves accessibility but also frees up valuable vertical space. A larger space allows users to view more content and reach it quickly.
However, there remains a challenge with the positioning of the tabs. To resolve this, we can remove the icons and reposition the Settings tab above the tabs. This adjustment ensures that the settings area belongs to the entire repository rather than just the code.
Regarding the icons, they serve as visual cues to help users quickly scan the UI. However, they are often poorly implemented. For example, repository-related icons are abstract and lack understanding, making them ineffective. GitHub has recognized this and dimmed the icons, acknowledging that users will read the labels anyway.
In addition to these changes, we can enhance the appearance of certain elements. For instance, moving the "Watchers" metric to the left side of the page increases its visibility and prominence. Furthermore, modifying the checkmark icon in the "Watch" button to be more conspicuous improves its readability.
Overall, these refinements aim to improve the usability and clarity of GitHub's interface, ensuring that users can navigate and interact with the platform more efficiently.
Written by urgent.news from Lobsters's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.