One MCP server, two rulebooks: shipping to Claude and ChatGPT
Sitecomb runs automated website quality audits. You paste a web address and it looks at six areas: security, privacy and legal, page health, works on phones, contact details, and found online. We also run it as a hosted MCP server, so you can ask Claude "is my website any good?" and get a real check back, not a guess. Here are five things we learned building that server. None of them are clever.…
Sitecomb is an automated website quality auditing service that can be run as a hosted MCP server, enabling users to ask Claude about the quality of their website. In this story, five lessons learned from building the server are shared. The first lesson is that the server runs statelessly, with a fresh server created for every request.
While this may seem wasteful, it doesn't require storing sessions, expiring data, or managing tool calls. The maximum runtime for a check is limited to 120 seconds, which includes the time to load the site and perform the check. This is crucial as the actual workload can take up to a minute. The second lesson is that the server has two host policies due to differing rules from OpenAI and Claude.
OpenAI's app rules prohibit upselling a digital product or showing prices, while Claude's directory allows linking to a paid report. Therefore, the server has one definition mounted twice with a slight policy object. The third lesson is that the model is instructed not to invent problems, fixes, or quality scores. Instead, it should report findings as they are and never add additional issues.
The fourth lesson is that public tools need limits, with each check costing real compute. The limits are set cheaply, starting with bad input and counters before the expensive browser load. The fifth and final lesson is that the tool description should be tailored to the questions people actually ask. Instead of using generic terms, the tool description should directly address common queries about website quality and provide clear guidance on its usage and limitations.
Written by urgent.news from Dev.to's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.