Yankees face a closer choice with a $23 million deadline

The New York Yankees find themselves at a critical juncture as they consider re-signing closer David Bednar for a $23.15 million qualifying offer. With the deadline approaching on November 17, the team must decide whether to accept the offer or face the prospect of losing the 35-save, 69 1/3 inning pitcher who converted a 2.47 ERA in 2026.

Re-signing Bednar would secure young talent, but the alternative could mean trading for experienced reliever Trevor Megill from the Milwaukee Brewers. Megill's trade value is substantial, having saved 30 games last season and sealing the Brewers' World Series championship. However, any trade would involve giving up valuable prospects and taking on additional risk.

The Yankees must weigh their options carefully, as relying solely on Bednar or Megill would not address all their bullpen needs. The team also has other relievers, such as Paul Blackburn, who are free agents, indicating that simply paying for a closer may not be enough to strengthen their late-inning options.