Schools blocking AI from student computers will now lose access to Google’s search feature, leaving edtech experts scratching their heads

Google's updated policy on AI tools for schools has sparked discussion among educational technology experts. The company announced that AI tools within its software for students will be restricted, a move that can be reversed by school administrators. Google stated this change aims to give K-12 classrooms more control over student AI engagement.

However, if schools entirely block AI, students will lose access to Google's Search feature, which is embedded with AI Mode and AI Overview. Critics argue this integration of AI into Google Search could have unintended consequences. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who imposed a one-year moratorium on generative AI for public schools, called Google's move an attempt to leverage its monopoly to promote its AI features.

Some experts believe that Google's insistence on integrating AI into Search might hinder its goal of AI integration in classrooms. They argue that the presence of AI Mode and AI Overview in Search makes it difficult for schools to allow students access to Search when AI is completely banned. This could potentially push schools back to traditional research methods, such as books and libraries.

Furthermore, Google's decision to not allow users to disable AI Mode or AI Overview on Search may even encourage a return to analog research tools, potentially threatening Google's presence in the classroom.