Why reforms alone won’t prevent a repeat of Tai Po fire
In the end, it was Winnie Ho Wing-yin, housing secretary at the time of the Wang Fuk Court fire in Tai Po, who took the rap. Her resignation came after weeks of talk within political circles suggesting that bureau chiefs would not have to bear responsibility for the tragedy that killed 168 people and displaced 1,984 families. These suggestions were met with shock. Some spoke out against such…
The aftermath of the Wang Fuk Court fire in Tai Po has left many questioning if reforms alone are enough to prevent similar tragedies in the future. Initially, it was housing secretary Winnie Ho Wing-yin who faced the brunt of the blame, ultimately resigning after weeks of debate about whether bureau chiefs should bear responsibility for the disaster.
Experts like Andrew Fung and retired officer Mike Rowse criticized the notion that political leaders alone should bear accountability. They emphasized Hong Kong's ministerial system, which holds political appointees accountable for failures within their watch, even if they were not directly responsible.
Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu acknowledged his own role in the tragedy and vowed to carry out necessary reforms. However, Lee argued that his ministers were answerable to him, not vice versa. The government's apology, coming nearly a year after the disaster, may not be sufficient to satiate public anger.
The independent investigation revealed that no government department took effective ownership of fire safety issues, with complaints about hazards going unaddressed. The Buildings Department and the Independent Checking Unit, tasked with supervising renovation work on the Wang Fuk Court, failed to coordinate and ensure safety. The report highlighted systemic issues, including a lack of crisis awareness, regulatory lapses, and enforcement failures.
Established in 2000 to oversee oversight post-a series of scandals, the Independent Checking Unit has now been deemed unfit for its intended purpose. Lee must realize that reforms are not enough; the government must also ensure that new systems function effectively to prevent future lapses.
Beyond reforms, a team under the Public Service Commission will assess the culpability of numerous officers and civil servants, aiming to uncover why the culture of buck-passing took hold. It is crucial to delve into the root causes of this failure, as both the system and its personnel let the city down.
Written by urgent.news from South China Morning Post's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
