What are the Worst MR Posts?
What are the worst MR posts, most illogical, poorly reasoned, low value, inconsistent? From the Archives, written by ChatGPT: These are provisional candidates for weak reasoning, selected because there is a specific gap between the evidence and the conclusion. This is not an objective ranking of all 40,326 posts in the downloaded archive. Poor reasoning […] The post What are the Worst MR Posts?…
1. Tyler Cowen - Democracy and the Democrats (October 22, 2022)
The main flaw in this post lies in the conflation of concerns about democratic breakdown with unwillingness to accept electoral defeat. Cowen argues that many Democrats believe democracy only works when it delivers low gas prices, but these are two distinct positions. The first assumes democracy is illegitimate when voters choose policies the author dislikes, while the second acknowledges voters might elect politicians who weaken democratic institutions.
The post fails to establish which position its targets hold and unnecessarily dismisses opposing viewpoints with an insulting remark, discouraging scrutiny needed for critical analysis. Despite the underlying point—that democracy can produce bad outcomes—it does not adequately establish the accusation being made.
Written by urgent.news from Marginal Revolution's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
