Austen adaptation a handsome, delicate cinematic dance

A new adaptation of Jane Austen's first published novel, Sense and Sensibility, has been released, eliciting mixed reactions from fans. Esmé Creed-Miles portrays Marianne Dashwood, a character often described as bedraggled, while Daisy Edgar-Jones plays Elinor, her more levelheaded sister. The film, directed by Georgia Oakley and written by Diana Reid, draws attention to the enduring relevance of Austen's themes, particularly sisterhood, which was also significant in Austen's personal life.

Purists may be discomfited by some deviations from the source material. For instance, Marianne's bedraggled appearance contradicts the casually coiffed look of the 2005 Pride & Prejudice adaptation. Additionally, the film explores the sisters' relationship more deeply, portraying their overlapping personalities rather than presenting them as strictly binary opposites. Elinor embodies sense, while Marianne embodies sensibility, but the film suggests a more complex connection between them.

The story follows the Dashwood sisters as they are displaced from their childhood home by patriarchal property laws. Elinor finds solace in a friendship with Edward Ferrars, a reserved character played by George MacKay, while Marianne becomes captivated by Willoughby, played by Frank Dillane, who is eager to pursue her attentions.

The film's interpretation of Austen's marriage plots is mixed, with the romance between Elinor and Edward being well-developed, while the characters of Willoughby and Colonel Brandon struggle with their limited roles.

While the film maintains a strong focus on the sisters' individual struggles and the constraints placed upon women of their time, it occasionally sacrifices Austen's social observations and humor in favor of a more introspective approach. Fiona Shaw delivers a standout performance as Mrs. Jennings, adding warmth to the production. Overall, this adaptation of Sense and Sensibility can be seen as a delicate dance, successfully capturing the spirit of Austen's work while presenting a fresh perspective on her beloved novel.