Jorge Polanco had one of the most disappointing seasons in Mets history in 2026

In 2026, Jorge Polanco experienced one of the most disappointing seasons in Mets history. The switch-hitting veteran was initially signed by the Mets to a two-year, $40 million contract following the Orioles' acquisition of Pete Alonso. However, the expectations for Polanco's production at the plate and his versatility in various positions did not materialize.

After a slow start in spring training to ease him into the long season due to previous leg injuries, Polanco primarily played first base for just two games during the season. Injury issues, particularly with his Achilles tendon and heel, sidelined him for most of the year, leading to him playing sparingly as a designated hitter (DH).

Over 145 plate appearances in 37 games, Polanco hit .148/.201/.230, posting a 20 wRC+ and a -1.4 fWAR. This performance was the worst in all of baseball since 2011, with the previous low point being Ronny Paulino's -1.2 fWAR season in 2009. Polanco's struggles were particularly surprising given his successful transition to DH in 2025 with the Mariners, where he thrived, indicating that his issues were likely due to his legs rather than his ability at the plate.

His age-33 season presents a significant question mark for the Mets, as they manage their 40-man roster this winter. Should he stick around, a favorable scenario would involve Polanco having an injury-free spring training as a DH, potentially returning to form in the regular season. However, the underlying metrics from Statcast suggest little optimism, and if he does not rebound, he may join Jed Lowrie and Frankie Montas as one of the Mets' most infamous signings.