Why some pro-Palestine activists have turned their backs on Mamdani

Despite being one of the most pro-Palestinian mayors in New York City history, Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing accusations of compromising his stance in favor of pro-Israel elements. New York City Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch and Mamdani attended a ceremony at the NYPD Memorial Wall on October 13, 2026, in the city. Mamdani campaigned on the issue of Palestine, repeatedly condemning Israel and labeling its war on Gaza as a genocide.

Upon becoming mayor, he rescinded two pro-Israel executive orders imposed by his predecessor, Eric Adams. He also used his first public meeting with President Trump to request the release of Palestinian activist Leqaa Kordia and vowed to arrest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if he visited New York, describing him as a war criminal.

However, Netanyahu was not arrested during his UN visit and Mamdani later stated he lacked legal authority to carry out the ICC arrest warrant. Pro-Palestine activists have since turned their backs on Mamdani, criticizing him for alleged compromises and lack of action.