Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across hundreds of outlets.

Science

Many learners in no-fee schools fall behind by Grade 3, study finds

A four-year Western Cape study found that learners in no-fee and low-fee schools were less likely to remain on track by Grade 3, despite some starting school developmentally ready.

Many learners in no-fee schools fall behind by Grade 3, study finds

A four-year study tracking learners across Western Cape schools reveals that children attending low-income or free education institutions are significantly more likely to fall behind in reading by Grade 3 compared to their peers in better-resourced schools. Funded by the Mr Price Foundation and conducted in collaboration with Stellenbosch University, the Roots & Shoots research followed 557 Grade R students from 75 public primary schools in five districts between 2022 and 2025.

Of the 75 participating schools, 91% serve disadvantaged communities and charge minimal fees. By the final assessment wave in 2025, 401 learners had been retested in Grade 3. The study found that only 49% of no-fee school students met the Grade 3 reading benchmark, compared to 92% of mid-fee school learners and 36% of low-fee school students.

Among students assessed in both the initial and final waves, the proportion deemed on track decreased from 56% to 40% in no-fee schools, and from 58% to 32% in low-fee schools. In contrast, mid-fee schools maintained high on-track rates from 88% to 90%. Octavius Phukubye, director of the funding organization, emphasized that while school readiness is crucial, it is not enough.

"Even when children begin school developmentally on track, many in poorer schools fall behind." Dr Heleen Hofmeyr, the lead researcher from Stellenbosch University, explained that following the same cohort over four years offered a clearer view of learning progression. The research found a gender literacy gap, with 60% of girls reaching the Grade 3 benchmark versus 42% of boys.

No notable gender disparity was observed in mathematics. These findings echo international research, which has shown that early developmental advantages are maintained only when children move into high-quality primary school settings. A Princeton University study highlighted persistent gaps in school readiness between children from lower and higher-income families, while a Tennessee-based study revealed that while effective teachers and quality schools help, both are essential to close achievement gaps.

The researchers stress that improving early learning requires addressing the unique needs of resource-poor schools by providing adequate funding, professional development, and learner support where they are most needed. The study underscores the importance of coordinated efforts among government, researchers, implementers, funders, and civil society to create systemic coherence in early childhood education, with government playing a pivotal role in ensuring equitable access to quality schooling for all children.

Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.

Source: iol.co.za

Read the original at iol.co.za →

Report a problem with this story

More in Science

More from Thursday 8 October →