As largest public employer, govt must set an example: SC
• Clear, predictable rules stressed for public servants • Administrative convenience can’t justify denying legitimate promotion, bench observes ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court has emphasised that the government, being the largest public employer, must conduct itself as a model employer, as good governance requires clarity not only at the policy stage but also in rule-making and subsequent…
The Supreme Court has emphasized that the government, as the largest public employer, must conduct itself as a model employer, highlighting the importance of clear and predictable rules for public servants. Justice Ayesha A. Malik, who authored the six-page judgement, stressed that the absence of coherent promotional tracks in rules can lead to governance failure, affecting both the institution and the employee seeking entitlements.
The case involved the restoration of Muhammad Shafiq's promotion from Elementary School Teacher (Physical Education) to Assistant Education Officer (Physical Education) after the Punjab Service Tribunal had previously withdrawn it. The court noted that reliance on a note in the Service Rules, which stated that the AEO post would be filled through transfer from the SST post, was not a valid basis for denying the promotion.
The rules, prescribed in 2014, clearly laid out the method for the promotion. The court observed that administrative convenience cannot replace the law, and ambiguity should not be used as a reason to deny legitimate progression. Good administration, the court emphasized, is measured by fairness, consistency, and efficiency in delivering what is due, rather than resistance to claims.
The broader rule-of-law consequence of such uncertainty is that the law cannot effectively regulate public servants if they cannot easily ascertain their duties. The court stressed that clear rules are not merely good drafting but are essential for fair, consistent, and accountable governance, emphasizing the responsibility of the State to address deficiencies in the service structure.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
Source: dawn.com
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
