Kerajaan tak boleh rampas dana bersih hanya kerana akaun ada ‘wang kotor’
Mahkamah Rayuan berkata Amla bukan ‘alat perampasan serba guna’.
The Federal Court ruled that the government cannot steal clean money solely because an account contains "dirty money", citing a RM360,000 tainted sum from a Hong Leong Bank account of LWC Good Service Sdn Bhd. The three-judge panel allowed LWC Good Service Sdn Bhd's appeal against the High Court's order to seize RM1.36 million from two of its bank accounts under the Anti-Wash Money and Anti-Promotion of Terrorism and Illegal Activities Act 2001 (Amla).
The appeal was heard by Judges K Muniandy, Azman Abdullah, and Dean Wayne Daly. Muniandy, who delivered the majority judgment, stated that the claimants had successfully proven direct links between the RM360,000 and the fraud-linked investment scheme, but there was no evidence connecting the remaining funds. The court ordered the seizure of RM360,000 from the Hong Leong Bank account, but ordered the return of RM863,179.84 from the same account and RM139,329.24 from a CIMB account held by LWC.
Muniandy emphasized that the Amla cannot be used as a universal tool to steal money based on a company's irregular corporate profile or lack of financial discipline. He ruled that unproven theft linked to illegal activities would result in unjustified asset seizure without legal authority under Article 13 of the Constitution. The court declared that the separation doctrine requires proven tainted money to be separated from clean funds in the same account.
LWC was among 28 respondents in the civil suit arising from the Comoncaps investment fraud scheme, which claimed losses of approximately RM3.49 million. The High Court previously ordered the seizure of the entire RM1.223 million from LWC's Hong Leong Bank account and RM139,329.24 from a CIMB account. The Federal Court found the High Court's decision to be flawed when it failed to distinguish the proven tainted RM360,000 from the remaining clean funds in the account.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
Other reports of this story
- Belanjawan NS: Kerajaan negeri boleh buat keputusan tanpa exco freemalaysiatoday.com