Judge criticises Nedbank for pursuing home auction despite higher private offer
A Mitchells Plain home valued at R699 000 attracted an auction bid of just R401 000, despite the owners having secured a private buyer willing to pay R650 000.
A Cape Town home's public auction by Nedbank was deemed unreasonable due to a higher private sale offer, according to a Western Cape High Court ruling. The house was put up for public auction in May 2025 after Nedbank secured a default judgment for R782,537. A reserve price of R470,000 was set, and the highest bid was R401,000, nearly R300,000 below the bank's valuation.
The homeowners had signed a private sale agreement for R650,000 with Standard Bank, which was nearly R300,000 more than the auction's highest bid. Judge Tandazwa Ndita found that Nedbank should have given the owners a reasonable opportunity to secure the remaining payment rather than proceeding with the auction. This case highlights a long-standing issue in South Africa, where homes have been sold at auction for as little as R1,000 or even R10, leaving defaulting homeowners with large debts to banks.
The 2017 court rules change, allowing judges to set reserve prices, aimed to protect homeowners and enable them to recoup some equity. In this case, the judge rejected Nedbank's demands for additional financial information and the homeowners' attempt to deduct legal fees from the sale proceeds. The R650,000 private sale will now proceed, with transfer and payment by 15 November 2026.
Written by urgent.news from The Citizen's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.