Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Culture

Estate fallouts expose challenges of posthumous art ownership

Recent US lawsuits, including a row over underpricing, reveal weaknesses in the market

Estate fallouts expose challenges of posthumous art ownership

As the transfer of wealth between generations is anticipated to accelerate in the years ahead, recent legal proceedings in the United States are shedding light on the prevalence of disputes that arise following the death of an artist or collector. John Moody, an Oregon man, has filed a lawsuit seeking to halt the sale of dozens of Chinese paintings at an estate auction, valued between $45 and $275 each.

The plaintiff contends that some of the works might be worth far more, with one piece potentially being a creation of the celebrated Chinese artist Xu Beihong; works by Xu have fetched auction prices reaching $41.9 million.

Rather than confronting the estate sale company directly, Moody's lawsuit accuses buyers of "knowingly" exploiting the "selling agent's failure to recognize the exceptional value of several rare Chinese art pieces." Although it may seem improbable that sales will be reversed, legal counsel in certain jurisdictions, such as France, allows for the annulment of sales under specific circumstances where a significant error has occurred.

Sarah Barker, the global co-head of art law at Withers, notes that while online inventories and available data are aiding in planning ahead, human error and familial difficulties in discussing succession still pose challenges in resolving issues for beneficiaries of artist estates. Furthermore, disputes concerning valuations and authenticity have dominated headlines this year, including a high-profile case in Canada where Jeff Cowan, an art fraudster, had his sentencing delayed due to allegations that the late artist Norval Morrisseau's estate participated in the forgeries.

Additionally, in April, a Manhattan jury awarded $102 million in damages to the Morgan Art Foundation, the former agent of Robert Indiana, after the publisher in question was creating and selling unauthorized works. Meanwhile, relatives of the late photographer Mike Disfarmer reached a settlement with the Arkansas Museum of Fine Arts concerning the copyright to hundreds of posthumous prints, following allegations of "illegal profiting."

These occurrences appear to echo the authentication debates of the 2010s, notably the Andy Warhol Authentication Board and the Basquiat estate discontinuing authentication services. The surge in available collections to the market is a significant contributing factor. In the United States, the first major generation of collectors is in the process of passing on and selling works, leading to an influx of comparable pieces.

Caroline Sayan, an art adviser at Cadell + Co., explains that this is due to the US appraisal structure, which was designed for tax and insurance purposes, not for sales. As a result, the numbers are widely misunderstood, and they were built for a different era. Sayan also points out that more stringent requirements surrounding provenance and exhibition history are creating barriers to accessing works that have been part of families' collections for generations, simply displayed or stored away.

She notes that what used to be a "golden ticket" for discovering undervalued pieces is now viewed as a "red flag."

Some artists and collectors are turning to technology for assistance. Caroline Taylor, from Appraisal Bureau, an online art ownership platform that recently integrated with the portfolio management platform Addepar, highlights that we are experiencing the largest intergenerational wealth transfer in history, alongside technological advancements that are fundamentally changing how collections are managed.

For the first time, families can maintain living inventories, receive independent valuations on a regular basis, and centralize documentation, thereby eliminating the need to treat estate administration as a posthumous endeavor. However, Taylor acknowledges that the primary challenge lies in collectors adopting these tools before an estate event, rather than after.

While the emphasis remains on traditional works, there is growing awareness of the importance of contemporary art, with demand rising in the Chinese market both at home and among international buyers.

Written by urgent.news from The Art Newspaper's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at theartnewspaper.com →

More in Culture

Making a Killing: Who profits from slaughter in Gaza and Yemen?

Making a Killing: Who profits from slaughter in Gaza and Yemen? Submitted by Fleur Hargreaves on Thu, 10/01/2026 - 17:23 New book by Andrew Feinstein traces $50bn in profit from the genocide in Gaza…

  • $50 billion in profit from conflicts in Gaza and Yemen
  • Western arms enable war in Yemen despite UK's pledge
  • Arms trade is backbone of state power under US hegemony

More from Monday 5 October →