The HOA state: what Florida can teach the rest of America about life under the tyranny of a condo association
About 78 million Americans live under 373,000 associations that can levy fines and even foreclose. Some are barred from voting and can't afford to leave.
Coretta, a Black mother of three and real estate expert, shared her concerns about living in a Florida community governed by a homeowners association (HOA). Over 20 years in her mostly Hispanic neighborhood, she felt the developers had pushed out those they deemed unwelcome. Coretta was one of 47 residents interviewed between 2017 and 2020 as part of a study on the experiences of people of color living in an HOA.
Many residents expressed that the HOA governing officials communicated a clear message that they did not belong there, regardless of their financial situation. In the U.S., 80% of new single-family homes in subdivisions and 60% of all new single-family homes are overseen by HOAs. While HOAs aim to maintain neighborhood aesthetics, they possess the power to enforce community restrictions, fines, and sanctions, and even have legal authority to foreclose on homes if homeowners fail to pay fees.
HOAs can regulate everything from paint color and fencing to cultural celebrations and community services. In this Florida community, the HOA did not allow proxy voting, meaning residents had to cast their votes in person on a Tuesday. The rules also excluded renters from voting and attending meetings, further excluding certain residents.
Approximately 373,000 HOAs in the U.S. affect the housing of over 78 million Americans. While federal laws limit HOA power, these organizations act as private governments with considerable control. Research shows they act as spaces of exclusion, maintaining residential segregation and favoring those with higher socioeconomic status.
Fewer than half of Americans living under an HOA believe their neighborhood benefits from the association, and 10% have considered selling their home due to HOA-related issues. HOA dues, typically around $230 monthly in Florida, can act as an exclusionary barrier for potential homebuyers. This exclusion often falls along racial lines and contributes to maintaining racial segregation.
Written by urgent.news from Fortune's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.