Bersatu’s RM10mil demand against defectors must stand up in court, analysts say
They say the amount stipulated in the party’s pledge cannot be enforced automatically.
Analysts argue that the RM10 million claim against elected representatives who leave the Bersatu party cannot be considered an automatic penalty. Instead, a court ruling should be sought, based on the documents and agreements they signed, according to experts.
Mazlan Ali from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia suggested that if elected representatives refuse to comply with Bersatu's demands, including vacating their seats, the party must take the matter to court. He emphasized the need to determine whether the party constitution's provisions are legally binding on its representatives. "If the matter is not brought to court, the lawmakers involved will certainly not comply with the demand," Mazlan stated.
Bersatu information chief Tun Faisal Ismail Aziz had previously warned elected representatives who leave the party to vacate their seats and pay RM10 million to the party. This warning followed Razali Idris, Bersatu Terengganu chief, hinting at his potential departure from the party via a social media post.
Ahmad Zaharuddin Sani Ahmad Sabri from Global Asia Consulting pointed out that the Zuraida Kamaruddin case demonstrated that the courts could recognize political bonds while assessing whether the stipulated amount was reasonable. In 2023, the High Court validated the RM10 million bond between Zuraida and PKR, but the Court of Appeal later reduced the amount payable to RM100,000, deeming the original sum disproportionate to the case's circumstances.
Ahmad Zaharuddin further explained that the court would examine the nature of the agreement, obligations, breach circumstances, and applicable compensation principles. The Zuraida case highlights that the document's stated amount may not be the ultimate award, suggesting that the court's decision will go beyond the initial financial threat.
Written by urgent.news from Free Malaysia Today's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
- Bersatu’s RM10mil demand against defectors must stand up in court, analysts say freemalaysiatoday.com