Bersatu’s RM10mil demand against defectors must stand up in court, analysts say
They say the amount stipulated in the party’s pledge cannot be enforced automatically.
The RM10 million demand made by Bersatu against elected representatives who leave the party cannot be considered an automatic penalty, according to analysts. Tun Faisal Ismail Aziz, the Bersatu information chief, warned that such representatives must vacate their seats and pay the substantial sum to the party. The warning came after Razali Idris, the Bersatu Terengganu chief, hinted that he might join a new party following a social media post about a "new platform."
Experts argue that the court should be the final arbiter in determining whether the Bersatu demands are legally binding on the defectors. Mazlan Ali from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia stated that if the lawmakers do not comply with the party's demands, the matter should be taken to court for a ruling based on the documents and agreements they signed.
Ahmad Zaharuddin Sani Ahmad Sabri of Global Asia Consulting pointed out that the Zuraida Kamaruddin case, where the court initially recognized a RM10 million bond between the former PKR MP and the party, but later reduced it to RM100,000, demonstrates that the courts assess the reasonableness of the stipulated amount in relation to the circumstances of the case.
He emphasized that the court would evaluate the nature of the agreement, the obligations agreed upon, the breach circumstances, and applicable compensation principles.
Mazlan Ali further noted that while political pressure from pledges and financial threats might incentivize elected representatives to remain in the party, they may not necessarily prevent them from leaving. The Federal Court recently reserved its decision on PKR's appeal to reinstate a High Court order for Zuraida Kamaruddin to pay RM10 million for breaching a party bond, further highlighting the complexity of such cases.
Written by urgent.news from Free Malaysia Today's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
Other reports of this story
- Bersatu’s RM10mil demand against defectors must stand up in court, analysts say freemalaysiatoday.com