REPORT CARD: Grading Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi’s cartel claims, 14 months later
Some thought the KwaZulu-Natal cop boss’s cartel infiltration accusations of 2025 were part of an elaborate, underhanded plot. Mounting evidence now suggests that he was instead outing real corruption.
In July 2025, South African police chief Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi issued allegations that a cartel had infiltrated the country's criminal justice system, politics, and private sphere. Some doubted the allegations, believing them to be a distraction from deeper corruption, but 14 months later, evidence suggests Mkhwanazi's warnings were accurate. The controversy has split the country's law enforcement into two factions - one backing Mkhwanazi, and one opposing him.
Debate surrounding Mkhwanazi's claims was reignited when Shadrack Sibiya, former deputy national commissioner of crime detection, accused Mkhwanazi of playing a "mind game" with the country. Sibiya, who has faced scrutiny over potential links to organized crime, was subsequently referred for disciplinary action and criminal investigation.
Critics argued that Mkhwanazi's accusations were a distraction from the malfeasance and financial misconduct within the Crime Intelligence unit. However, recent developments have seen criminal charges against several Crime Intelligence officers withdrawn, further solidifying Mkhwanazi's stance.
The Madlanga Commission of Inquiry and Parliament's ad hoc committee were established to investigate Mkhwanazi's allegations. Several individuals implicated in the broader scandal have since been arrested, placed on leave or suspended, including politicians, law enforcers, and business figures. Politicians, law enforcers, and business figures implicated in the scandal face criminal charges, suggesting there is truth to the initial accusations.
The cartel allegedly controlled by the Big Five, a reference to a drug syndicate, was also exposed. Suspected members of the Big Five include Vusimuzi "Cat" Matlala and Katiso Molefe, both of whom face various criminal charges. Matlala has been linked to political funding efforts involving Senzo Mchunu, while ANC-aligned information peddler Brown Mogotsi is also in state custody after being accused of faking his own assassination attempt.
Written by urgent.news from Daily Maverick's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
