Ex-CIA chief David Petraeus warns US has technology but no strategy to win wars
The technical advantages enjoyed by the US military have been undermined by the Pentagon’s failure to develop strategies to exploit them, Gen David Petraeus has said in a strong criticism of Washington 's approach to warfare. The former commander of US forces in Afghanistan also condemned the American withdrawal from the country in 2021. “I do not believe we had to leave Afghanistan when we did,…
Former CIA director David Petraeus has criticized the United States' approach to warfare, stating that the country possesses advanced technology but lacks a strategy to effectively utilize it. Speaking at the UK's House of Lords, Petraeus expressed his belief that the 2021 withdrawal from Afghanistan was premature and unnecessary, arguing that the US should have maintained a military presence to counter the advancements demonstrated by Ukraine.
He emphasized that Ukraine has become a crucial military laboratory for the 21st century, showcasing the importance of technology combined with a strategic approach to warfare. The former head of US Central Command questioned whether the US innovation ecosystem is transforming its military rapidly enough to exploit its technological advantages.
Despite the US boasting the most dynamic innovation ecosystem globally, Petraeus questioned the speed at which the military can adapt to these advancements. He highlighted the failure of the US to bring Iran to the negotiating table, despite having superior weaponry, and emphasized that no nation can secure enduring strategic advantage solely through the acquisition of better technology.
Ukraine's ability to adapt its software, create its own precision strike methods, and effectively utilize drones has demonstrated the potential of technology when paired with a suitable strategy. The former CIA director criticized the US withdrawal from Afghanistan, asserting that the coalition's military commitment had reached a sustainable level.
However, the sudden withdrawal announced by President Joe Biden in April 2021 significantly contributed to the collapse of Afghan forces. Petraeus argued that the US had not translated its tactical superiority into a decisive political outcome in Afghanistan, raising concerns about the effectiveness of President Donald Trump's broader Middle East policy.
Regarding the UK's military position, Petraeus praised Britain's ability to adapt to the new form of warfare showcased by Ukraine, stating that the country is uniquely positioned to reorganize its armed forces based on the lessons learned from the conflict. He urged the UK to become the first major western nation to adopt this new concept of warfare, which could help lead the transformation of NATO itself.
Written by urgent.news from The National UAE's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
