‘He’s Got More Ability Than Shedeur Sanders’ — NFL Insider Backs Browns’ Surprise Deshaun Watson Decision for QB1

On August 22, 2026, the Cleveland Browns officially announced their starting quarterback for the 2026 season, selecting veteran Deshaun Watson over controversial second-year player Shedeur Sanders. While many fans had hoped Sanders would secure the position, the decision has been met with mixed reactions, particularly after Watson received a hostile reception from the crowd during his previous game appearance.

However, not all NFL insiders share the same opinion as the majority of Browns supporters. ESPN's Jeremy Fowler, an NFL expert and Cleveland-based correspondent, weighed in on the quarterback controversy and expressed his belief that the team made the correct decision in favor of Watson. "I think it’s the right move. He’s got more ability than Shedeur Sanders," Fowler stated. "He’s a better athlete. Todd Monken’s offense requires a lot of responsibility."

It is worth noting that Fowler’s perspective is not surprising, considering his deep connection to the AFC North and his extensive covering of the Browns. As the Ravens’ offensive coordinator during the 2024 season, Fowler has a thorough understanding of Monken’s offensive scheme and its requirements.

Despite his success in the past, Watson has faced numerous challenges since joining the Browns. Injuries have been a recurring issue, most notably, a torn Achilles tendon that forced him to miss the entire 2025 season. Even before that injury, Watson's performance had been subpar. During the 2024 season, he led the team to a disappointing 1-6 record and threw a meager five touchdowns compared to three interceptions.

Conversely, Sanders' performance last season was equally disappointing, with a PFN QB Impact Rating of 63.0, placing him second-worst among NFL quarterbacks. However, Fowler believes that Sanders' lack of success may have played a significant role in the Browns' final decision.

With Watson now confirmed as the starting QB, the Browns might still face changes in their quarterback position throughout the 2026 season. The team's overall win projections are among the lowest in the league, and their history of QB struggles has made the search for a franchise player a perennial challenge. The Browns are likely to continue their search for a new franchise quarterback in 2027, but for now, they are banking on Watson to lead them off the field.