The surprising backstory behind a popular cold 'remedy'
A Nobel Prize winner's book is at the root of the idea. But he was not a dietitian or an infectious disease physician.
In the 1970s, renowned chemist Linus Pauling published a book claiming that consuming high doses of vitamin C could prevent and treat the common cold. Despite his prestigious accolades—including two Nobel Prizes—Pauling, who was not a dietitian or infectious disease physician, based his claims on a single placebo-controlled trial and four other studies. However, his analysis of these studies was criticized for mathematical errors, reliance on low-quality trials, and an overemphasis on a study involving children.
Research conducted after Pauling's book largely refuted his assertions. Multiple studies since then have shown that any potential benefits of vitamin C on colds are minimal at best, with effects only observable under specific circumstances such as in athletes or during military service. A 2023 meta-analysis of ten placebo-controlled trials involving 2,736 participants found that vitamin C reduced severe cold symptoms by 15% on average, primarily measured by the number of days spent indoors due to illness. However, the supplement did not reduce the duration of mild symptoms.
Another study from 2013 revealed that lower doses of vitamin C (around 200mg daily) did not decrease the number of colds in the general population but showed a reduction in severity for athletes and military personnel. Regular vitamin C supplementation also showed a 8–14% reduction in symptom severity for both children and adults, yet taking it at the onset of symptoms had no effect.
From these analyses, Pauling's original advice is considered overstated. There is no evidence that vitamin C reduces the risk of most people contracting a cold. If severe symptoms last for five days, vitamin C may reduce them by approximately 12 hours, and by about two-and-a-half hours if the symptoms last for 24 hours. Importantly, starting vitamin C supplementation once symptoms appear is ineffective.
To maintain good health, Pauling suggested a daily intake of 1,000–2,000mg, which is close to the upper limit considered safe. In Australia, where the upper limit is set at 1,000mg a day, the recommended daily intake for adults over 19 is 45mg, found in small quantities of fruits and vegetables. High doses of vitamin C can pose adverse health risks, prompting those interested in taking supplements to consult with their GP and adhere to recommended dosages.
Written by urgent.news from SBS News's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.