A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit accusing Harvard University of mishandling complaints of anti-Semitism against a prominent student group. The lawsuit, filed in 2018, targeted the Harvard chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine. The complainant, a Jewish student who brought the lawsuit, claimed that the university had failed to take adequate action against the group for allegedly harassing Jewish students. But Judge Allison D. Burroughs ruled that the university's actions did not amount to a breach of contract or violate the student's free speech rights. The lawsuit had claimed that Harvard had violated the student's contractual rights as set out in the university's policies and had also infringed her right to free speech. Students for Justice in Palestine has been at the centre of controversy over its events and social media posts. In 2017, the group sparked outrage by hosting an event featuring a convicted Palestinian militant. The event prompted a backlash from Jewish students and faculty members, who accused the group of promoting anti-Semitic views. Harvard had faced criticism for its handling of the controversy, with some accusing the university of not doing enough to combat anti-Semitism on campus. The university had said that it was committed to combating anti-Semitism and ensuring a safe and inclusive environment for all students. The dismissal of the lawsuit is a significant development in a case that had been closely watched by free speech advocates and critics of academic institutions. The case had raised questions about the limits of free speech on university campuses and the responsibilities of institutions to protect students from harassment. The ruling is likely to have implications for universities across the US, where debates over free speech and anti-Semitism have been intensifying. Harvard University has said that it is committed to protecting the rights of all students and promoting a culture of respect and inclusivity.
A lawsuit filed by the Trump administration against Harvard University for alleged anti-Semitism has been dismissed by a court. The court determined that the administration's evidence was insufficient to prove that Harvard University continued to violate the federal civil rights law. The Justice Department, while not agreeing with the ruling, is reviewing further actions.
U.S. District Court Judge Richard Stoneman, in Massachusetts, accepted Harvard's request to dismiss the lawsuit filed by the Trump administration on November 13. Judge Stoneman found that the administration's listed anti-Semitic incidents were not enough to prove that Harvard was still in violation of the law. The Trump administration had filed the lawsuit in March, alleging that Harvard had failed to address anti-Semitism and discrimination against Jewish and Israeli students, violating Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.
Title VI prohibits discrimination based on race, color, or national origin by institutions receiving federal financial assistance. The administration claimed that Harvard had effectively ignored the boycott of Israeli students after the 2023 Gaza War. However, Judge Stoneman noted that most of the cases presented in the lawsuit occurred during the 2023-2024 academic year, and subsequent events were "isolated and intermittent," which did not support the claim that Harvard continued to violate the civil rights law.
The Justice Department has not ruled out appealing the ruling. The Department of Justice's civil rights official, Mark Hall, stated that "we disagree with this ruling and are reviewing further actions." This ruling does not end the legal dispute between the Trump administration and Harvard University, as a federal court in Boston ruled in September that the Trump administration's move to cut $2 billion in federal research funding to Harvard was improper. The administration has appealed this decision and the case is ongoing.
Written by urgent.news from Hankyoreh's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
