Saudi Arabia to hand over COP presidency to Mongolia at COP17

The story of Saudi Arabia's failed attempt to defeat the Houthis reveals a decade of strategic miscalculations that could now drag the Kingdom back into war. This analysis, based on the provided source, explores the complex dynamics that led to this outcome.

Key facts from the source:

1. Yemen was never truly one country, but a forced union between North and South. North Yemen, governed by a Zaydi Shia Imamate, was a fiercely independent warrior society, while South Yemen was a Sunni-majority maritime society influenced by Indian Ocean trade routes and British administration.

2. In 1990, the two halves united, creating a ticking geopolitical time bomb. The resulting state was less a unified nation and more prone to instability.

3. In 2014, the Houthis, a Zaydi revivalist movement backed by Iran, seized control of Sana'a and the north. The alliance with former President Saleh proved fatal for him, as the Houthis executed him in 2017.

4. Saudi Arabia's response to the Houthis was a massive conventional air campaign. However, the anti-Houthi coalition ultimately secured territorial gains through ground operations by the UAE and local fighters from the South.

5. The Stockholm Agreement in 2018 brokered by UN Secretary-General António Guterres aimed to end the conflict, but Saudi Arabia halted the offensive, allowing the Houthis to retain control of key infrastructure like Al-Hudaydah and its maritime routes.

6. Political missteps by Saudi Arabia, such as attempting to build a post-war government around the Islah Party (Muslim Brotherhood) and forcing an Islah-dominated government on the South, alienated effective military allies from the South.

7. Saudi Arabia entered a prolonged ceasefire with the Houthis, legitimizing them while quietly restocking Houthi arsenals with Iranian missiles and weapons.

8. The Houthis capitalized on Saudi Arabia's miscalculations, now holding the Bab al-Mandeb Strait and choking global energy corridors. Saudi Arabia found itself alone, unable to exploit the geopolitical window to crush the Houthis.

The root cause of Saudi Arabia's failure lies in its repeated confusion between political ambition and strategic judgment. By prioritizing Islamist forces over military realities and choosing a hollow ceasefire over tactical resolve, Riyadh alienated key allies and lost the trust of southern forces. Consequently, if Saudi Arabia re-enters the Yemeni conflict, it will do so without the critical support of the UAE and southern forces that delivered significant battlefield gains.

The true cost of Saudi Arabia's decade-long strategic miscalculations was not its lack of military power, but its poor strategic judgment.