We did a Trader Joe's Thanksgiving grocery haul in NYC and a smaller Northwest city. The cheaper one might surprise you.
Thanksgiving is approaching, and Trader Joe's newsletter, Fearless Flyer, has a suggested menu.
In a comparative analysis of Thanksgiving grocery shopping at Trader Joe's in New York City and a small Northwest college town, Business Insider reporters Gabbi Shaw and Tristin Hoffman discovered that the Manhattan location offered a marginally cheaper experience. Both shoppers adhered to the retailer's pre-curated Thanksgiving menu from the Fearless Flyer newsletter, which provided guidance on selecting meats, side dishes, and desserts.
In New York City, Shaw visited a Trader Joe's in Manhattan during the mid-morning on a Tuesday, noting the store's packed crowds and lack of easy parking, despite its architecturally pleasing design. Here, she acquired an organic turkey priced at $33.42 for a 13.42-pound bird, along with spiral-sliced uncured ham for $52.44 for an 8-pound portion, complete with a glaze packet. Additionally, Shaw purchased a turkey gravy box for $1.69 and a cornbread stuffing mix for $4.99.
In the Northwest college town of Eugene, Tristin Hoffman faced the absence of a sales tax, which contributed to a potentially more budget-friendly shopping experience. She selected organic green beans for $3.49 and persimmons at $3.99 per pound. The selection of cheeses offered a wider variety, with notable items like Stilton cheese at $5 for a portion and triple-cream Brie at $13.99 per pound. Hoffman also opted for a sweet onion salad kit priced at $3.99.
When comparing the two locations, the Trader Joe's in Manhattan proved slightly more affordable overall. While the turkey and ham prices were higher in Eugene, the absence of sales tax may have compensated for this difference. Shaw's purchases at the New York City Trader Joe's totaled around $108.85, while Hoffman's experience in Eugene amounted to approximately $109.92. Despite the minor price discrepancy, both locations provided a range of options for a budget-conscious Thanksgiving meal.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.