UPI was never free. But is its new merchant fee fair?
UPI's new MDR brings the cost of digital payments into focus. But questions remain over how the revenue will be distributed, whether smaller merchants and consumers will bear the burden, and if the framework adequately addresses competition and transparency in India's digital payments ecosystem.
UPI, India's popular digital payment system, has never been truly free. Instead, various entities have been footing the bill through subsidies, technology budgets, and lower interest rates on savings. With over 24,000 crore transactions worth Rs 314 lakh crore in FY26, UPI processes more than half of the world's real-time payments by volume, according to the IMF. The new Merchant Discount Rate (MDR) aims to make this cost more transparent, though the fees remain a contentious issue.
The MDR, set at 0.4% on payments above Rs 2,000, is lower than Indonesia's QRIS (0.7%) and China's wallets (around 0.6%), but still higher than Brazil's Pix (about 0.22-0.33%). Compared to card payments, UPI's fee is relatively modest. However, for merchants receiving up to Rs 1 lakh a month, there is no charge, and certain sectors like railways, fuel, utilities, and insurance pay a flat Rs 5. UPI handles about 50% of these transactions, making it a crucial player in India's digital economy.
For context, a merchant receiving Rs 75,000 via NEFT incurs no charge, but the same transaction via UPI would cost Rs 300 plus GST. This differential cost structure raises concerns about fairness, especially when the effective rate for higher-value transactions could reach about 0.15-0.20%. Banks take a significant share of this fee, leaving a smaller pool for other stakeholders like acquirers, apps, and payer PSPs.
The debate about UPI's fee is complicated by the presence of a few dominant players, such as PhonePe and Google Pay, which control about 80% of the user-facing market. This concentration in the market raises questions about interoperability and how it might affect competition and distribution.
The government has introduced a 30% volume cap on any single app, but this measure has been deferred several times and remains largely unenforced. The IMF notes that large technology firms benefit from these payment systems, gaining steady income and valuable data. The new fee is intended to cover these costs and support the broader ambitions of the key players involved.
While the fee is meant to cover operational expenses, critics argue that it could lead to price hikes for consumers, particularly for one-time payments above Rs 2,000. This could undermine the benefits of microfinance and other services that have moved away from cash transactions. The passing of the charge to the customer could inadvertently force shops to raise prices, making the ultimate cost of a Rs 500 charger indirectly pay for a Rs 50,000 phone.
Suggestions for reform include fixing the fee at Rs 100 for now and revisiting it every two years based on audited cost data, similar to how the US Federal Reserve manages debit card fees. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) should set the rate, rather than NPCI, which collects most of the fee. Additionally, reducing the app's share of the fee as volumes rise could help level the playing field, while the RBI should set tiered rates after public consultation.
Other proposals include removing the Rs 5 charge on loan repayments, as these are not purchases, and holding acquiring banks accountable for surcharges. The Rs 2,000 and Rs 1 lakh limits should be adjusted for inflation. To build trust, NPCI has postponed the rollout until after Diwali, and a public interest petition is currently pending in the Supreme Court. The time could be better spent refining the design rather than reevaluating the need for a fee altogether.
Written by urgent.news from YourStory's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.