MSCI Is Cutting Strategy and Metaplanet From Its Indexes. Here's What It Means for Bitcoin Treasury Company Stocks.
Key PointsMSCI will remove Strategy and Metaplanet from its indexes at the close of Nov. 30.
MSCI announced on November 11 that it will remove Strategy (MSTR) and Metaplanet (MTPLF) from its indexes due to their heavy reliance on Bitcoin holdings. Strategy, a software company that has turned into a Bitcoin treasury, will be deleted from the MSCI USA Index by November 30. Metaplanet, a Japan-based Bitcoin treasury peer, is also being removed from the index. Ethereum treasury company SharpLink (SBET) will be placed on a new public watch list.
This decision is the result of a year-long dispute. Initially, MSCI proposed excluding companies whose digital-asset holdings made up 50% or more of total assets. However, the idea was dropped in January after receiving objections from over 250 organizations. In August, MSCI introduced a broader screen targeting "non-operating companies" based on five financial-ratio flags. A company must meet four of these flags to be excluded.
In its response to the proposal, Strategy labeled it as "pretextual," suggesting that MSCI may be inventing reasons to exclude Strategy. The company asserts that its Bitcoin business is an operating segment of an established software company, a claim that follows discussions with SEC staff. However, the index removal is unlikely to have a "meaningful impact" on Strategy's business, according to the 10-page letter.
Strategy's focus after the announcement was on its preferred stock, credit markets, and Bitcoin-per-share metrics. Executive Chairman Michael Saylor and CEO Phong Le held a special investor call on November 19, emphasizing these topics. They discussed the company's buybacks of preferred stock and its shrinking organic demand for a 12% instrument. The buybacks aim to find a floor for the stock price.
Despite the removal from the index, Strategy's market value is approximately 63% of its Bitcoin holdings. The stock trades at a slight discount to its underlying Bitcoin reserves. Index funds tracking MSCI benchmarks will need to sell their Strategy and Metaplanet shares by the end of November, leading to potential forced selling.
Strategy has a $4.7 billion U.S. dollar reserve, covering about 3.4 years of interest and dividends, providing a significant cash cushion. However, this cushion alone is not a catalyst for growth without the index bid.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.