Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Culture

Illinois couple erect fence after trespass, car theft; HOA wins order to move it

Illinois couple erect fence after trespass, car theft; HOA wins order to move it

In an Illinois neighborhood, a fence meant to enhance safety for a family has sparked a legal dispute with their homeowners association (HOA). Vincent and Lekeisha Williams erected a fence around their property after experiencing repeated trespassing incidents and a stolen car. However, the HOA challenged the placement, citing community restrictions. The dispute reached an appellate court, which upheld an earlier order for the couple to remove the fence.

The Appellate Court of Illinois explained that the disagreement arose from the Williams family's concern for their safety, including multiple police calls about trespassers near their bedroom window. Their vehicle was also stolen from the yard. To address these issues, they built a fence to protect vulnerable areas, such as windows and an electrical box. While the structure initially helped prevent further incidents, its location led to tensions with the Ashford Farms HOA.

The Illinois court ruled that the subdivision's restrictive covenants required homeowners to obtain written approval before installing fences or making certain changes. The HOA's architectural committee had previously rejected the Williamses' preferred placement but later proposed a compromise. However, the couple positioned the fence closer to their home, leading to a compliance notice and a 30-day deadline to address the violation. The HOA subsequently sued to enforce the neighborhood restrictions.

At a bench trial in October 2024, the Williamses argued that other properties in the subdivision had fences that violated similar rules. They also presented evidence of the trespass incidents and explained that the proposed alternate location would not provide adequate protection near their bedroom window. However, the HOA's property manager testified that another homeowner with a fence in a similar situation was also sued and required to remove it.

In April 2025, the trial court ruled in favor of the HOA, finding that the couple had installed the fence without the necessary approval and ordered them to move the fence back to the approved location within 120 days. The court denied the HOA's request for attorney fees. The Williamses appealed, claiming that their fence complied with the subdivision's rules and questioning the HOA's selective enforcement of the regulations.

They also challenged the architectural committee's approval process, arguing that they had not responded within the required 60-day period.

The Appellate Court of Illinois, Fifth District, denied the appeal and confirmed the lower court's decision in a November 17, 2026 ruling. The judges emphasized that the couple needed to obtain architectural approval, even if the fence did not extend to the street. The committee had only permitted installation halfway along the house, not at the front.

The court also determined that there was insufficient evidence of selective enforcement, as the alternative homeowner had already undergone similar legal proceedings and was instructed to take down their fence.

Additionally, the appeals panel dismissed the 60-day approval argument since the Williamses had not raised the issue during the initial trial. The court noted that the HOA was not given the opportunity to respond to this new argument at the appellate stage. Consequently, the ruling upholds the original order to relocate the fence, requiring the Williamses to move it to the position approved by the HOA.

Written by urgent.news from Times of India's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at timesofindia.indiatimes.com →

More in Culture

Palisades Fire Suspect Jonathan Rinderknecht Found Guilty of Starting Deadly Blaze After Retrial

Twelve people were killed and 6,000 structures were destroyed in the January 2025 fire The post Palisades Fire Suspect Jonathan Rinderknecht Found Guilty of Starting Deadly Blaze After Retrial…

  • Jonathan Rinderknecht found guilty of starting Palisades Fire in 2025
  • 12 people killed, 6,000 homes destroyed in deadly blaze
  • Sentencing scheduled for March 17, 2027, with 5-40 year range

More from Saturday 21 November →