Google told schools to accept AI or lose Search. Now 3 of America’s 4 largest districts are pushing back
Chicago, New York and Los Angeles have restricted student AI. Now Google says keeping Search means accepting AI Overviews, and Miami-Dade, a Gemini partner, isn’t saying how it will respond.
Google has placed schools in a position where they must choose between allowing students to use AI tools or losing access to Google Search. In August, Google began displaying Gemini AI summaries in Google Classroom by default for K-12 students whose schools had already approved its AI chatbot, Gemini. However, on November 3, Google reversed its stance, stating that its AI tools will be disabled for K-12 student accounts unless school administrators enable them starting early next year.
Google has made it clear that schools wanting students to have Google Search will have to accept AI Overviews, the AI-generated summaries that appear at the top of search results. Chris Phillips, Google's vice president for education, stated that schools that do not permit AI will not have access to search and will see a message from their school indicating that it is unavailable.
Many school districts have restricted or banned student AI use due to safety and privacy concerns, and this decision may have left them questioning Google's reasoning. The decision comes as tech companies face increasing legal pressure over harm to children. In March, a Los Angeles jury ruled that Meta and Google's YouTube were negligent for failing to warn users about the dangers of their platforms.
In January, Google and Character.AI agreed to settle lawsuits from families claiming their children were harmed by its chatbot. A family also recently filed a lawsuit against Google, alleging their 13-year-old daughter planned her suicide using Gemini on her school-issued Chromebook and that Google pushed its AI products on students without informing parents or schools.
Google claims it is developing new Gemini features to help students work through problems without immediately getting answers. The country's four largest school districts have responded differently to Google's ultimatum. Chicago Public Schools has blocked students from using AI tools such as ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and other third-party AI products.
The district is exploring alternative options to suppress AI Overviews in Google searches. New York City Public Schools has placed a one-year moratorium on student-facing AI and banned companion chatbots in all grades. They have also requested to know if Google will allow students to use Google Search without AI Overviews, given the company's history of restricting features for young users.
Los Angeles Unified has blocked generative AI for students on district-issued devices, while Miami's largest school partner is facing new challenges.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.