Double taxation on the Highway: Why tolling Nairobi-Thika Road punishes commuters twice
Motorists using the Nairobi–Thika highway could face a new financial burden under the Government’s proposed tolling plan, even as they continue paying taxes and levies intended to finance road construction and maintenance. The proposal has reignited debate over whether Kenyans should pay separately to use roads that are already supported by public funds. For thousands […]
The Nairobi-Thika highway, a vital route connecting Nairobi with surrounding towns, is facing a potential financial burden from government plans to introduce tolls on the road. This proposal, part of a Public-Private Partnership arrangement, would see a private investor fund the highway's construction and maintenance, with tolls used to recover the investment.
However, critics argue that motorists would be paying twice for the same infrastructure: once through existing fuel taxes collected at fuel stations, and again through direct toll charges at highway collection points.
The Road Maintenance Levy Fund (RMLF) currently finances road maintenance through a charge on every litre of petrol and diesel sold in Kenya. Essentially, motorists contribute to road infrastructure every time they refuel, regardless of whether they use a tolled highway. The proposed tolling system would add another payment, linked directly to road usage. This raises questions about whether Kenyans should bear separate costs for roads already supported by public funds.
The National Treasury acknowledges that the existing fuel levy may be insufficient to cover the road network's growing maintenance needs, estimating annual maintenance requirements to be Ksh253.5 billion, far exceeding projected RMLF collections of Ksh100 billion. The government suggests that tolling could provide additional financing, reducing reliance on the national budget.
However, critics argue that this distinction fails to alleviate the financial burden on regular commuters. Daily traffic on the Thika Road, serving thousands of workers, students, and business owners, would face repeated transportation expenses. For private motorists, the additional toll charge would mean more costs on top of fuel, insurance, and vehicle maintenance. Public service vehicles transporting passengers could also face higher operating expenses, potentially passed on to commuters through increased fares.
Small businesses reliant on the Thika Road corridor for transporting goods could encounter higher distribution expenses, affecting the prices of goods and services. The proposed tolling could particularly impact workers who have limited alternatives but must commute daily between Nairobi and surrounding towns. A seemingly minor toll fee could become a substantial monthly expense for someone using the highway multiple times a day.
The debate over tolling the Nairobi-Thika highway underscores the challenges Kenya faces in financing its expanding road infrastructure without placing undue financial strain on citizens. Private-sector investment offers one solution, but raises questions of affordability and accountability. The government must balance the need for additional funding with the fairness of imposing additional costs on regular commuters who already contribute to road maintenance through fuel taxes.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.