Criticism from Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan cut Trump’s sway over Republicans in half in experiment on the Epstein files
A new study tested whether Republicans would punish Trump for opposing the release of the Epstein files. Democratic criticism changed nothing. Pushback from Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan cut his sway roughly in half.
Republican voters are often seen as unquestioningly following Donald Trump’s lead, even when his positions are unpopular. However, a new study published in Public Opinion Quarterly reveals that Trump’s sway over his base is not unbreakable. The research, conducted by Love Christensen and Mattias Agerberg from the University of Gothenburg, focused on the controversy surrounding the release of government files linked to Jeffrey Epstein.
The findings indicate that criticism from conservative media personalities Tucker Carlson and Joe Rogan effectively weakened Trump’s influence on policy attitudes and reduced his approval ratings. The study suggests that blind loyalty to a dominant political figure may not stem from an unbreakable cult of personality, but rather from a lack of trusted opposition within the leader’s own ideological group.
The researchers explain that Trump reversed his position on the release of the Epstein documents in 2025, contradicting his previous populist stance and alienating a majority of Republicans who favored disclosure in a recent poll. This decision led to harsh criticism from influential voices like Joe Rogan and Tucker Carlson, both of whom had endorsed Trump and advocated for transparency.
The study aimed to determine if Republican partisans, often perceived as having a cult-like devotion to Trump, would still support him on an issue that garnered significant media attention and public support for file release. Christensen and Agerberg designed two preregistered survey experiments in September and October 2025, conducted via the online platform Cint.
They recruited U.S. adults who identified as Republicans, ensuring they confirmed their political affiliation and passed a preregistered attention check. By presenting participants with the Epstein files controversy, the researchers were able to assess whether Republican voters would continue to follow Trump’s lead despite vocal opposition from conservative media figures.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.