Chasing hot themes, hypergrowth stocks or multibaggers? Why Rajeev Thakkar of PPFAS Mutual Fund prefers fundamentals
Rajeev Thakkar, PPFAS Mutual Fund CIO, emphasizes the importance of fundamentals over trendy investments. He compares Coal India with a popular stock to highlight valuation concerns. Thakkar discusses misconceptions about earnings growth, suggesting attractive investments can have zero growth if they provide dividends. He addresses investor worries regarding artificial intelligence and its impact…
In an investment climate where many are tempted by trending sectors, rapid growth stocks and the possibility of substantial returns, PPFAS Mutual Fund's Chief Investment Officer and Director, Rajeev Thakkar, underlines the significance of focusing on a company's fundamental strengths over simply chasing popular investment trends.
During PPFAS's 13th Unitholders’ Meet, Thakkar elaborated on why the fund does not actively seek out companies expected to become multibaggers. He stressed that investment choices are based on a company's business quality, financial performance, and valuation rather than the buzz around a specific sector or theme.
To support his argument, Thakkar compared Coal India, a constituent of the fund's portfolio, with another company that is highly popular among investors due to its sector-related appeal. He explained that this comparison was not meant to disparage the other firm, but to highlight why the price paid for growth matters. While Coal India generated over Rs 1.71 lakh crore in revenue and more than Rs 33,000 crore in profit, the other company reported significantly lower revenues and profits.
Despite this, the other company carried no dividends and traded at a much higher price-to-earnings (PE) ratio of over 700. In contrast, Coal India offered a 6.6% dividend yield and a much lower PE of around 7.
Thakkar also highlighted past investment trends to emphasise the importance of not overpaying for companies with strong growth prospects. He cited a scenario where a company that had tripled its profits over five years saw its stock price drop by nearly a third - all because the initial valuation was unrealistically high. Even with a threefold rise in profits, the stock remained overvalued, with a PE multiple exceeding 70.
This example showed that even a well-managed, high-growth company may not be a sound investment if it is purchased at an excessively high price.
Thakkar also addressed the common belief that companies with high earnings growth are always better investments. He pointed out that a company with zero earnings growth could still be attractive if it generates cash flows equivalent to its earnings and distributes all its profits as dividends. Using a hypothetical example, he explained that a stock trading at five times its earnings and paying out all its profits as dividends would yield a 20% dividend.
Even if the earnings stayed constant for 25 years, Thakkar would consider investing in such a business due to the recurring cash flows it offers shareholders.
The fund manager clarified that investment decisions should not solely be based on earnings multiples or growth rates. Investors must evaluate both the potential for growth and the reasonable valuation offered by the company. Thakkar also tackled several misconceptions about what equity fund managers should and should not do. He made it clear that the PPFAS team does not attempt to forecast quarterly earnings, interest rate fluctuations, FPI flows, geopolitical events, or political developments, as these factors are largely beyond the control of fund managers.
He also acknowledged the growing importance of artificial intelligence (AI) and its potential to create significant opportunities. However, Thakkar cautioned that the rapid capital expenditure in the AI sector could lead to disruptions over the next few years. Additionally, he noted that the availability of open-source AI models could alter the competitive landscape, making it essential for investors to consider the long-term value of a company's offerings beyond a single AI model.
Regarding PPFAS's investments in Indian IT services companies like TCS, Infosys, and HCL Technologies, Thakkar clarified that these stocks represent less than 10% of the fund's portfolio. He also reassured investors that the fund house is not overexposed to the IT sector and remains cautious about the potential disruption that AI could bring to traditional software services. Thakkar highlighted that while market narratives about AI could sometimes become exaggerated, they often present hidden investment opportunities.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.