The quiet identity crisis behind AI productivity gains
My work in organisational psychology and clinical practice has increasingly brought me into conversations about how AI is changing people’s sense of professional identity. One client, whose identifying details have been changed to protect confidentiality, leads a research team at a Singapore fintech company. AI has transformed how she works. Reports that once required hours […] The post The quiet…
The rapid adoption of AI in the workplace is reshaping how professionals view their roles and contributions, raising questions about identity, competence, and achievement. This transformation is particularly evident in the corporate sector, where AI tools are enabling employees to produce work at unprecedented speeds. For instance, in Singapore, 66% of AI users report creating work they couldn't have achieved a year ago, compared to 58% globally.
These productivity gains are attractive to businesses seeking to scale, but they often overlook the psychological impacts on employees.
A study involving 3,562 participants across four experiments found that while generative AI improved immediate task performance, it also led to lower intrinsic motivation and increased boredom when employees returned to tasks they performed independently. This shift in work dynamics challenges the traditional understanding of professional identity, which is built through effortful mastery.
Tasks that once helped establish a person's expertise and demonstrated their capabilities are increasingly being handled by AI, leading to a perceived erosion of achievement and confidence.
Research from Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon University surveyed 319 knowledge workers who regularly use generative AI. The findings suggest that confidence in AI correlates with less critical thinking effort, while confidence in one's abilities correlates with more. However, this does not imply that AI causes skills to deteriorate.
Instead, it raises questions about how people maintain their self-efficacy when fewer opportunities exist to exercise their abilities independently. Over time, this could lead to a cycle where increasing dependence on AI technology makes independent performance feel more difficult, despite overall productivity improvements.
The imposter phenomenon, traditionally characterized by capable individuals struggling to internalize their achievements, takes on new dimensions with AI. Employees may produce excellent work with AI assistance while becoming uncertain about which parts of the process reflect their own expertise. This uncertainty can foster further reliance on AI, reducing opportunities to practice and develop independent skills.
From a clinical perspective, maintaining a sense of self-efficacy becomes crucial when the skills years of development are used differently. Rather than assuming reassurance will address these concerns, it is important to explore which aspects of someone's work still depend on their expertise and how they can continue developing their abilities.
Leaders in organizations need to recognize the importance of retaining human skills such as critical thinking and make these contributions visible. While AI can produce much of the initial output, acknowledging the decisions, errors caught, and improvements made by employees is essential for preserving a sense of mastery and professional value.
Written by urgent.news from e27's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.