Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Finance & Markets

The entrepreneurship scorecard is broken. We’re measuring the wrong things.

What happens when the business doesn’t work?

The entrepreneurship scorecard is broken. We’re measuring the wrong things.

The stories we choose to tell about entrepreneurial success often overlook a critical question: what happens when the business doesn't work? At the Tetr College of Business, students have had firsthand experience of both sides of this experience. While they have built businesses, taken products to market, acquired customers, and managed costs, some have discovered that their original assumptions did not hold up.

When we analyzed outcomes across cohorts, it wasn't just the revenue generated that stood out, but the considerable variation in what was built, earned, and lost. This distinction matters because entrepreneurship is rarely a linear progression from idea to success. It's an exercise in navigating uncertainty, making decisions with incomplete information, and constantly reconciling ambition with market realities.

The current methods of measuring entrepreneurial success, such as counting companies launched, capital raised, revenue generated, and founders who build something meaningful, leave out a crucial aspect. Revenue tells only part of the story. For example, 59 student-built drop shipping businesses generated over $172,000 in reported revenue with a 21.86% profit margin.

However, individual businesses had varying scales and economics. Bike Arena generated $102,361 in revenue with a 21.98% profit margin, while Tafflo generated $18,008 in revenue with a 63.64% profit margin. Smaller ventures like Juvak, a gaming accessories brand, generated $2,396 in revenue with a 53.21% profit margin, and Claycia, a curated bag brand, generated $5,342 in revenue with a 12.47% margin.

Direct-to-consumer ventures also demonstrated different levels of commercial performance. While 21 student-founded brands generated $186,862 in revenue with an average profit margin of 30.62%, businesses like Elantherm, which developed wearable period-relief belts, generated $1,906 in revenue but recorded a $900 loss, and Welz Company, which sold smart rings, generated $2,491 in revenue with a $369 loss.

These losses highlight that sales do not automatically translate into profit. The real question is what founders do with this information. They may revisit pricing, rethink distribution strategy, reconsider the customer they are trying to reach, or recognize that the original idea needs to change altogether. The market is a more demanding teacher than we often realize.

Kickstarter campaigns offered another perspective. Seventeen student teams raised $79,532 from over 1,100 backers, exceeding their combined funding goal of $75,000. However, some campaigns failed to meet their funding targets, such as ClickBuddy, which reached only 67% of its funding goal, and Brett, which reached only 80%. These statistics underscore the importance of interrogating the numbers rather than explaining them away, as learning to recognize when an assumption is wrong and having the judgment to change course can be as consequential as the conviction to pursue an idea in the first place.

Written by urgent.news from Fortune's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at fortune.com →

More in Finance & Markets

More from Friday 20 November →