Stellenabbau: So vermeiden Führungskräfte die teuersten Fehler bei der Abfindung
Freistellung, Bonus, Dienstwagen: Bei der Verhandlung zählt jedes Detail – Manager verschenken leicht einen fünf- bis sechsstelligen Betrag. Eine Checkliste und Beispielrechnungen zeigen, worauf es ankommt.
German companies are currently laying off workers at a rapid pace. The German industry alone has cut over 120,000 positions last year. To encourage employees to resign, firms offer large severance packages. For instance, BMW aims to release 8,000 employees quickly and entices them with a super premium. Insiders from the industry reported to Handelsblatt about individual cases where BMW has agreed to payments of over 650,000 euros.
Mercedes currently offers severance packages up to 330,000 euros in production. Labor lawyer Christoph Abeln, who specializes in representing executives, warns against hastily signing separation contracts. "Signing a termination contract hastily can be very costly," he says, warning that seemingly large sums are often just a waste of money.
The Handelsblatt article explains the details of severance negotiations, highlighting that often more is possible than the social plan promises. The applicable right to severance pay in Germany does not exist universally. While there is a general right to severance pay during restructuring with layoffs, the business council and employer often draft a social plan that defines severance pay based on social criteria like employment duration or number of children.
This is one of the rare cases in German labor law where the employee has a severance claim that cannot be taken away. The statutory severance pay, known as the "rule severance" under the Kündigungsschutzgesetz, is half a month's gross salary per year of employment. For a salary of 8,000 euros and 15 years of service, that would amount to 60,000 euros.
Importantly, the sum stipulated in the social plan is only a minimum, even if employers try to suggest otherwise. However, individual severance pay can often be higher, especially for long-serving executives without a justifiable reason for dismissal. A full month's salary per year of employment is considered standard. Business council members are excluded from the validity of the social plan, including chief executives and business leaders.
Abeln cites a practical example: a marketing director at a German insurance company receives a severance offer of over 700,000 euros - seemingly a considerable amount. However, a closer look reveals it's not as substantial as it seems. The 55-year-old manager earns 450,000 euros annually before tax, and the employer also contributes 50,000 euros annually to his pension fund.
By the time the earliest non-earmarked retirement age of 65 is reached, these additional amounts would amount to around 500,000 euros. These rights go with the termination contract, as the manager's own severance payment would leave them with 360,000 euros after taxes. Worthwhile to keep For each month the employment contract remains in effect, there is a salary claim.
André Kasten, an employment lawyer from Abeln's firm, explains that the notice period is worth money in a severance dispute. Companies often try to negate this advantage by offering a sprint premium to anyone who signs quickly. Because such financial incentives usually only amount to up to three months' gross salary, a quick departure only makes sense in specific cases, such as when a new position is already in sight.
Bonus, company car, and holiday leave should also be negotiated in the separation contract. These often decide on the majority of the actual value. Focusing solely on the severance amount means leaving money on the table. The case of a sales director with a gross annual salary of 300,000 euros demonstrates this. Lawyer Kasten negotiated 12 months of salary continuation plus an additional six months to compensate for the competitor restriction.
This amounted to an overall package worth 390,000 euros. Restricted stock rights should also be taken into account in the severance calculation. These are common incentive systems for executives of listed companies. After a certain period - often after three years - the manager can buy the company's shares at a fixed price, or they are regularly allocated.
If the manager leaves the company prematurely without fault, the severance calculation must also consider their acquired rights. Often, the rules in the employment contract, particularly the "Good-Leaver/Bad-Leaver" clause, determine whether and under what conditions the manager retains or loses their financial entitlements. Finally, the so-called "Fünftelregelung" was the most important tool for reducing the tax burden of severance pay until 2025. With a high single payment, the tax rate is significantly increased.
Written by urgent.news from Handelsblatt's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.