Siri Recap Hands-On: Private, But Not Very Useful
With the watchOS 27.3 beta , Apple started testing Siri Recap. ‌Siri‌ Recap lets the Series 12 and Ultra 4 Apple Watch models listen to conversations to generate a brief summary of what was discussed. Actual audio is sectioned off from apps, Apple, and the rest of the OS, and then discarded after a summary is generated. It's a privacy-forward way of tracking what's going on around you,…
Apple has been testing Siri Recap through the watchOS 27.3 beta. This feature allows the Series 12 and Ultra 4 Apple Watch models to listen to conversations and generate brief summaries. Actual audio is separated from apps and discarded after summary generation, ensuring privacy. However, after two weeks of testing, it's clear that privacy safeguards limit its usefulness.
Siri Recap's overly brief summaries, lack of speaker labeling, and absence of original audio make it unreliable. Despite being a beta feature, some issues could potentially be resolved before the public release in December. My experience with Siri Recap involved watching YouTube videos and Instagram Reels, which it could not distinguish from real-life conversations.
This made it feel invasive. Other summaries were of inconsequential conversations with my partner, which I wouldn't need to revisit. Siri Recap performed best in summarizing shorter, less important interactions, but longer conversations were too concise and inaccurate. It combined unrelated details into nonsensical summaries, even in critical conversations with the vet.
Siri Recap does not label speakers, so summaries often became confusing amalgamations. In some cases, it omitted important medical information, like surgical risks and resuscitation preferences. While Siri Recap captured fact-heavy conversations well, especially those involving dates, it sometimes missed crucial details. The conciseness of its summaries led to a shift in my memory of the actual conversation, making me question its accuracy.
Although Apple promises that Siri Recap won't include financial information, it's unclear what qualifies as such. The feature's ability to interpret spoken medication names, like benazepril and clopidogrel, was surprisingly accurate. However, I worry that having notes that aren't my own might overwrite my memory of the conversation, leading to inaccurate recollections.
Overall, I don't trust Siri Recap to make decisions about what to keep or omit from conversations. While I wouldn't want a version that records full conversations due to privacy concerns, I'm uncertain if Apple has created a version that balances usefulness and privacy.
Written by urgent.news from MacRumors's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.