Paid sick leave laws are no guarantee for Philly’s immigrant restaurant workers
Doctor’s note requirements, industry norms and fear of retaliation prevent many immigrant restaurant workers in Philadelphia from using paid sick leave.
Philadelphia workers who are employed by private companies with more than 10 employees may be eligible for paid sick leave, as required by the city's laws. Philadelphia joins a growing number of states and cities that mandate paid time off for workers who become ill. Theoretically, this allows sick workers to recover and prevent the spread of germs, without sacrificing their earnings. However, the benefits of these laws may not be as straightforward for immigrant restaurant workers in the city.
Philadelphia's paid sick leave law has been in place since 2015. During the COVID-19 pandemic, federal and local laws temporarily expanded these protections. The Families First Coronavirus Response Act, enacted on March 18, 2020, and amended by the CARES Act later that month, required private-sector employers with less than 500 employees to provide 80 hours of paid sick time annually to full-time employees.
Additionally, a 2022 temporary expansion of Philadelphia's local paid sick leave law mandated private-sector employers with 25 or more employees to provide 40 hours of additional paid sick leave to eligible employees.
Despite these policies, several factors make it difficult for workers to take advantage of them. Many restaurant workers in Philadelphia, particularly immigrants, face unique barriers. During the pandemic, employers sometimes violated the law or misunderstood policies. Even when workers were under the weather, they were often discouraged from calling in sick due to long-standing service industry norms.
Employers typically required doctor's notes for paid sick leave, except for absences of more than two days, as stipulated by the local law. However, undocumented immigrants like Bill, a server from Mexico, found it challenging to obtain health insurance due to their immigration status. Without insurance, he would have had to pay a significant amount for a simple flu treatment, deterring him from claiming sick pay.
Furthermore, restaurants often have different policies for back-of-house workers, who work in the kitchen, and front-of-house workers, who interact with customers. In the kitchen, where immigrant workers from Latin America were predominantly employed, the chef required proof of a doctor's visit and recommended rest before paying out sick days.
In contrast, front-of-house workers, mostly nonimmigrant employees, were not required to provide proof and seemed to receive more lenient treatment from managers. Socorro, a prep cook, observed that immigrant kitchen workers were often assigned the most challenging tasks and faced greater restrictions on sick days. Additionally, immigrant workers feared retaliation from employers if they requested paid sick days, making it difficult for them to assert their rights under the law.
Written by urgent.news from The Conversation's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.