Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across hundreds of outlets.

Tech

If you stop writing code, you also get worse at reviewing it

Article URL: https://cekrem.github.io/posts/if-you-stop-writing-code-you-also-get-worse-at-reviewing-it/ Comments URL: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50573886 Points: 324 # Comments: 159

When learning a new skill, it is essential to practice it regularly. Reading about the skill is beneficial, but without hands-on experience, the knowledge won't translate into proficiency. This principle applies to software engineering, where hands-on practice is crucial for improving problem-solving abilities and code quality.

Contrary to the belief that one can maintain or even enhance their skills without practice, this approach is not viable in any field, including software engineering. To illustrate this point, the author compares the situation to that of a musician who stops practicing and relies solely on providing feedback to others. It is likened to an author who stops writing and only reads and gives feedback to other writers, or worse, even consumes AI-generated prose. The author argues that this approach would result in a steady decline in their writing skills.

The author emphasizes that when practicing a specific skill, it is not just the end product that matters but the skill of the craftsman. The same logic applies to software engineering, where understanding how code works, recognizing good code, identifying potential issues, and grasping the importance of software architecture are equally vital. Simply reviewing all the code generated by an AI like Claude is not sufficient for maintaining or improving one's code proficiency.

To ensure continuous improvement, the author recommends that software engineers always keep practicing, even if the need for hands-on coding varies depending on the situation. The author strongly believes that the moment one stops practicing problem-solving, their skills will deteriorate, just like any other skill or craft. Repeated usage of LLMs for problem-solving can lead to the belief that effort is unnecessary, which is detrimental to learning and personal growth.

The author concludes by cautioning against relying heavily on AI for various tasks, such as summarizing books or seeking therapy. They draw parallels to the slippery slope of declining literacy and numeracy rates and question whether people are still thinking for themselves when they rely heavily on AI. The author ends by wishing that John Scofield continues playing his guitar, urging the importance of practicing and honing one's skills.

Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.

Read the original at cekrem.github.io →

Report a problem with this story

More in Tech

More from Friday 20 November →