Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Culture

Gerrymandering Is Still Bad

The fact that the practice didn’t succeed in thwarting the Black vote this time is not a point in its favor.

Gerrymandering Is Still Bad

Republicans suffered significant losses in the midterms, leading some to claim that fears about gerrymandering, diminished Black representation, and undermining democracy were overblown. However, this conclusion is incorrect. While Republicans did not gain as many seats as they hoped, their efforts were still effective in limiting the damage and maintaining large majorities in certain states where Democrats received a significant portion of the vote.

According to The Wall Street Journal, the midterms disproved the notion that America is "structurally" racist, as minority candidates across the country won races. Conservative columnist Quin Hilyer argued that even with post-Cailas redistricting, Black candidates performed well. However, this reasoning is flawed, similar to Sideshow Bob in The Simpsons insisting on his innocence despite attempted murder charges.

Democratic voters overcame attempts to protect GOP incumbents by turning out in unprecedented numbers. Even if Republicans kept the House, they succeeded in limiting damage and maintaining large delegations in states where Democrats came close to winning or won more than half of the votes.

In contrast, Democratic gerrymanders gave Republicans a disproportionately higher number of seats than their vote percentage. For example, in Texas, Democrats won more than half of the popular vote but only 14 seats, while Republicans secured 24, nearly double that. Similarly, Democrats won 48% of the vote in Florida but only 8 out of 28 congressional districts. In California, Republicans will control 4 out of 52 seats despite winning only 30% of the vote.

While some gerrymanders backfired by assuming incorrectly about the midterm electorate, the fact that Republicans did not succeed in thwarting voter will does not make the gerrymandering right. The issue of voter suppression still exists, and it is not justified simply because some attempts failed. Democratic maps may not be as effective, but they still leave Republicans with a significant advantage in some states.

Written by urgent.news from The Atlantic's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at theatlantic.com →

More in Culture

More from Friday 20 November →